As a long time fan of the series, both old and new, I would say that the 9th series is an improvement upon the prior season. Moffat has a leaning toward plot over character, and so, a series full of 2-parters lets his storytelling shine better than in prior seasons. That said, no series is perfect, and there are a few clunkers this season. But, it is overall an improvement in quality. The set itself is an improvement as well, with more special features and commentaries than the previous series sets. It also contains 2 holiday specials given the timing of the series and how long we will have to wait for the next series to air. Overall, an improvement all around.
I've been a fan of the series off and on since I was 12. Watched the 4th and 5th Doctors on PBS, and even caught the occasional 1 and 2 series there. Been watching since the 2005 reboot and have liked each of the actors in the role and thought I would like Capaldi as well...I have had a hard time enjoying his character, and it isn't his fault. his acting is good, but I feel the writing has not given him a chance.
After a rough season/series 8 the 9th season is an improvement. Less focused on Clara and more on the Doctor...this helps the version of the character grow some. But it still falls into the current Moffit trend of trying to build a giant puzzle out of the season...easter eggs like the words Bad Wolf or Vote Saxon in earlier seasons were fun when they paid off, but Moffit tries to make the audience feel dumb for missing the clues. Fingers crossed season 11 with a new crew writing and directing will breath new life into the show.
I got this for my 13 year ol daughter. She loves it. We got nonbluray to play on long car rides.
I would recommend this to a friend
Rating 5 out of 5 stars with 1 review
Excellent show, and great transfer.
Its hardwired structure that requires major change every so often is one of the main reasons Doctor Who is thriving 50+ years after it debuted. As someone who started watching back when Tom Baker was The Doctor, I can safely say that this season/series has one of the best episodes of the entire run of the show: Heaven Sent. Yes, it's that good.
This set has everything for the Whovian. It features all of the episodes from the previously releases of Series 9, Part One and Part Two, plus the Christmas specials, Last Christmas and The Husbands of River Song. It also includes all of the special features. That means it contains all of the content of four separate releases.
Another excellent season with some small quibbles. Most of the season consists of 2 part episodes which was annoying when watching live, not so much on the blu ray. I found Clara's exit as awkward and unfulfilling as the Ponds. And overall the season was quite dark. Lots of extras on the set. Get it on sale and it's a good buy.
This season of the 12th Doctor's is vastly improved and overcame the uneven tone of his first season. The biggest change in this series is the number of two part stories that still exist into an overall arc of events. Even more impressive is Capaldi's solo performance in an episode that makes "Groundhog Day" look like a walk in the park. Also an added bonus is the closure to the River Song story line in "The Husbands of River Song."