Black Friday is hereShop new DoorbustersShop now

Main Content

Customer Ratings & Reviews

Customer reviews

Rating 4.6 out of 5 stars with 400 reviews

Rating Filter

Pros mentioned filter

Cons mentioned filter

94%
would recommend
to a friend

Customers are saying

Customers highly value the game's impressive graphics, engaging story, and the overall quality of the remaster. Positive feedback also highlights the enjoyable action and authentic driving experience, although some found the controls and certain racing sequences challenging. A few players noted that the open world felt somewhat limited. Despite some minor criticisms, the game's positive aspects appear to outweigh the negative for most players.

This summary was generated by AI based on customer reviews.

The vast majority of our reviews come from verified purchases. Reviews from customers may include My Best Buy members, employees, and Tech Insider Network members (as tagged). Select reviewers may receive discounted products, promotional considerations or entries into drawings for honest, helpful reviews.
Page 2 Showing 21-40 of 400 reviews
  • Pros mentioned:
    Action, Story

    Rated 5 out of 5 stars

    Had to add this one to my collection

    |
    |
    Posted . Owned for less than 1 week when reviewed.
    This reviewer received promo considerations or sweepstakes entry for writing a review.

    I have the other Mafia games in this series and even though I had the digital copy of this game I had to get the physical copy especially at the sale price Best Buy had it for. Now we are enjoying the story and action. I still have to say that the first Mafia is my favorite but this game comes in a close second.

    I would recommend this to a friend
  • Pros mentioned:
    Graphics, Story

    Rated 5 out of 5 stars

    It's great, buy it!

    |
    |
    Posted . Owned for less than 1 week when reviewed.
    This reviewer received promo considerations or sweepstakes entry for writing a review.

    It took me to play through the game for about 9 hours at a reasonable pace to also explore the world but focus on the story. While I was playing the story, it felt well done and interesting and I could imagine playing through the story again. The main character Tommy Angelo who you get to play with felt good but also sad the further into the story you get.

    I would recommend this to a friend
  • Pros mentioned:
    Game play, Graphics, Story

    Rated 5 out of 5 stars

    Mafia definitive edition

    |
    |
    Posted . Owned for 1 week when reviewed.
    This reviewer received promo considerations or sweepstakes entry for writing a review.

    Great game fun good visuals , fun ,open world , story , missions .

    I would recommend this to a friend
  • Pros mentioned:
    Graphics

    Rated 5 out of 5 stars

    Fun Game

    |
    |
    Posted . Owned for 1 year when reviewed.
    This reviewer received promo considerations or sweepstakes entry for writing a review.

    Fun game. Great graphics. Brings back nostalgic memories.

    I would recommend this to a friend
  • Pros mentioned:
    Graphics, Story

    Rated 5 out of 5 stars

    The game is good

    |
    |
    Posted . Owned for 2 weeks when reviewed.
    This reviewer received promo considerations or sweepstakes entry for writing a review.

    I played this game when it came out on the ps2 and loved it but this remake is still as awesome as the ps2 just with better graphics and the story is freakin awesome. The game is linear but if you like really great stories and wanna play something good? Play mafia you will enjoy it

    I would recommend this to a friend
  • Pros mentioned:
    Graphics, Story

    Rated 5 out of 5 stars

    A great game that's worth the money

    |
    |
    Posted . Owned for 1 month when reviewed.
    This reviewer received promo considerations or sweepstakes entry for writing a review.

    A welcome return to one of the greatest games every made. Highly recommend - the story is great as ever, with some nice additions, and the update to graphics, gameplay, etc. was handled well. There are some quirks to it, but they've been updating regularly since launch and most of these have been mitigated.

    I would recommend this to a friend
  • Pros mentioned:
    Game play, Story

    Rated 5 out of 5 stars

    Great story

    |
    |
    Posted .
    This reviewer received promo considerations or sweepstakes entry for writing a review.

    Never got to play the first mafia just 2 & 3 when they was released but I have to say I enjoy the story and good game play. Still Mafia 2 is the pinnacle of this franchise for me but great game

    I would recommend this to a friend
  • Pros mentioned:
    Graphics, Story

    Rated 5 out of 5 stars

    Cool game

    |
    |
    Posted . Owned for 2 months when reviewed.
    This reviewer received promo considerations or sweepstakes entry for writing a review.

    I'm glad they remade this game since I have Mafia 2 and 3 and they are both fun. Great graphics and story highly recommend if your a fan of the series. The world is very detailed and takes place during the prohibition era.

    I would recommend this to a friend
  • Pros mentioned:
    Graphics
    Cons mentioned:
    Voice acting

    Rated 4 out of 5 stars

    Great remaster! Bad voice actor for Paulie!

    |
    |
    Posted . Owned for 9 months when reviewed.
    This reviewer received promo considerations or sweepstakes entry for writing a review.

    This remaster totally made this game much better than the original Mafia, but there is only glaring problem: Paulie's voice actor. He sounds annoying, and no where near as good as William DeMeo back in the day. If you can ignore the voice actor for Paulie and focus on how well they remastered this game, you're in for a real treat.

    I would recommend this to a friend
  • Pros mentioned:
    Graphics, Story

    Rated 5 out of 5 stars

    Great

    |
    |
    Posted . Owned for 3 weeks when reviewed.
    This reviewer received promo considerations or sweepstakes entry for writing a review.

    Great game exactly like the original just better graphics. Original storyline and freeplay. Its great for people who didn't play it the first time it was released.

    I would recommend this to a friend
  • Pros mentioned:
    Graphics, Story

    Rated 4 out of 5 stars

    A true remake

    |
    |
    Posted . Owned for 2 weeks when reviewed.
    This reviewer received promo considerations or sweepstakes entry for writing a review.

    Fun mafia game. A true remake from the ground up not just a remaster. Graphics are great, especially for the city, although sometimes the faces look a little funny. Story is fun and engaging but it's a little short by modern standards. They've also added a sandbox mode you can access from the main menu so you are able to run around the city.

    I would recommend this to a friend
  • Pros mentioned:
    Graphics, Story

    Rated 5 out of 5 stars

    Fantastic

    |
    |
    Posted .
    This reviewer received promo considerations or sweepstakes entry for writing a review.

    Wow this game is amazing. I’ve been playing this game since I was a kid so seeing this game remastered is absolutely mind blowing. The graphics and story are amazing!

    I would recommend this to a friend
  • Pros mentioned:
    Graphics, Story

    Rated 5 out of 5 stars

    Great game

    |
    |
    Posted . Owned for 1 month when reviewed.
    This reviewer received promo considerations or sweepstakes entry for writing a review.

    Good gameplay. Great remaster from the original Mafia game years ago. I'd say this is better than Mafia 2 and 3. The music, graphics and story add such depth and immersiveness to the game.

    I would recommend this to a friend
  • Pros mentioned:
    Game play
    Cons mentioned:
    Racing

    Rated 4 out of 5 stars

    Mafia definitive edition

    |
    |
    Posted . Owned for 3 weeks when reviewed.
    This reviewer received promo considerations or sweepstakes entry for writing a review.

    I really enjoy the game play it’s different from what I’m use to playing. I enjoy all the old cars on it and police chase you if you speed in the cars. The racing is hard than I thought it would be. Overall it pretty decent game to play.

    I would recommend this to a friend
  • Pros mentioned:
    Graphics, Story

    Rated 5 out of 5 stars

    Nice game

    |
    |
    Posted . Owned for 3 months when reviewed.
    This reviewer received promo considerations or sweepstakes entry for writing a review.

    Nice game with pretty cool graphics and a entertaining story to it! Got me entertained for hours trying to finish it to know the end of the main character!

    I would recommend this to a friend
  • Pros mentioned:
    Game play, Graphics

    Rated 5 out of 5 stars

    Mafia remake

    |
    |
    Posted . Owned for 3 weeks when reviewed.
    This reviewer received promo considerations or sweepstakes entry for writing a review.

    Mafia remake is an amazing game. They took a classic game and really went above and beyond with game play and graphics. It really has that true gangster feel.

    I would recommend this to a friend
  • Pros mentioned:
    Graphics, Story

    Rated 5 out of 5 stars

    OG Mafia GTA

    |
    |
    Posted . Owned for 3 months when reviewed.
    This reviewer received promo considerations or sweepstakes entry for writing a review.

    Very good remake, better than the Mafia 2 remaster!! Great story, fun gameplay, and awesome characters. Best game to be an Italian gangster!

    I would recommend this to a friend
  • Pros mentioned:
    Remaster

    Rated 5 out of 5 stars

    Great mafia / open world game!

    |
    |
    Posted .
    This reviewer received promo considerations or sweepstakes entry for writing a review.

    Amazing remaster of a great game. Great for a discounted price ($20 during black Friday) and also still worth it for a little more.

    I would recommend this to a friend
  • Pros mentioned:
    Graphics, Story

    Rated 5 out of 5 stars

    Mafia remastered

    |
    |
    Posted . Owned for 3 weeks when reviewed.
    This reviewer received promo considerations or sweepstakes entry for writing a review.

    Great game. Worth the buy, remaster of graphics and content makes it worth playing, story allows for hours of game play.

    I would recommend this to a friend
  • Pros mentioned:
    Graphics, Story

    Rated 4 out of 5 stars

    Not bad, good story

    |
    |
    Posted . Owned for 8 months when reviewed.
    This reviewer received promo considerations or sweepstakes entry for writing a review.

    I enjoyed the story and the gameplay for the most part. There were some glitches and some skipping of story that made no sense but I still liked the story.

    I would recommend this to a friend
Sponsored