Customer Ratings & Reviews

The Lord of the Rings: Tales of Middle-earth is easily one of the most immersive sets ever released. Whether you're a die-hard Tolkien fan or a competitive player, opening these packs feels like stepping directly into the books. ​Why it Earns 4 Stars: ​Flavor-First Design: The attention to detail is staggering. Every card name, ability, and flavor text feels authentic to the lore. The "The Ring Tempts You" mechanic adds a unique layer of strategy that feels thematic without being overly broken. ​Stunning "Showcase" Art: The alternate art styles—especially the Scrolls and Poster treatments—are some of the most beautiful cards ever printed. Pulling a legendary character with a unique border is a genuine thrill. ​Modern & Commander Powerhouses: Between staples like The One Ring, Orcish Bowmasters, and fantastic legendary creatures for Commander, the power level is high. These cards didn't just stay in the set; they defined formats. ​The Experience: There is a certain "magic" to casting Gandalf or Aragorn that regular sets just can't replicate. It’s a nostalgia trip that actually plays well. ​The Missing Star: ​The Price Tag: As a "Universes Beyond" premium set, the packs are notably more expensive than a standard release. While the card quality is there, the cost-to-pull ratio can be tough if you don't hit one of the top-tier mythics. ​Complexity for Newcomers: While the theme attracts new players, some of the mechanics (like tracking Ring-bearer abilities) can be a bit much for a first-time player to manage during a busy game. ​The Verdict: This is a must-buy for anyone who loves Lord of the Rings. It’s a premium experience with high-value hits and incredible art, though your wallet might feel the "corruption" of the Ring after a few packs.

Always a great experience while shopping at Best Buy . Before I entered the store at 9:59 am at the a Woodland Hills, Ca branch . I saw a Best Buy employee cleaning up the store front area prior to entry before being opened. I was shocked that the manager was the one who gave the direction to the employee, it was not dirty some miscellaneous trash debris but as a manager he knew that a clean house is a welcomed house. 10:00 am the doors open and at first entry is a two customer service employees asking if I need any direction to finding my product, I asked and was immediately directed to the area where it will be found. Ty Best Buy for running a respectable business who looks after their customers.

Best cards I ever bought. Nostalgia 100% plus not going to lie made little money out of few cards

Amazing set. One of the best of all time. This is what Universes beyond was made for.

Hit the one ring in the first pack. Lots of good cards to be found.

Exactly what I wanted. Came in great condition and sealed with original packaging. No tears or rips. Purchased in-store.

I loveee the art on all of these cards. Truly a classic collection

Pulled the one ring supper thrilled. Will buy more.

Exactly as advertised. Lord of the Rings Booster pack, which are hard to find. I got lucky my last purchase of two packs and got a foil Orcish Bowmasters and The One Ring. Thank you for keeping them always in stock!

Had cards when other places didn’t. The prices of the cards were almost 50 percent lower than other places. It’s always great to come to Best Buy and find things you can’t find anywhere else and at a better price.

Retail price is cheaper than buying a booster box for lord of the rings. normally it's the other way around but bb keeps the price competitive as compared to others.

Awesome set. Would definitely recommend to new and old players.

Fun pulls. Nothing too good from them but that is the way of the cards.

Definitely hit the jackpit here, opened maybe 6 to 8 packs and pulled The One Ring. The packs definitely paid for themeselves for sure. So it was fine day for collecting with all the additional cards as well.

Great selection of cards! Best Buy has been my go to place for Magic recently especially since they stock up relatively older sets.

Out of 5 packs I scored three Nazgûl and one was a foil!!

A good magic set for value, it has a lot of cedh staples in it for those competitive edh players.

Great art work and the series goes extremely well with the original overall theme of Magic the Gathering.

MTG is a fun, especially Lord of the Rings. Got a Orcish Bowmasters in one of the packs. Quite happy.

Lord of the rings! My precious! Got a fun frodo and sauron