Customer Ratings & Reviews

I would love to be able to review this item, however I have still not received it as it has been sitting in a fulfillment center for 2 weeks. It is a Christmas gift and I hope it arrives in time.

It wasn’t really appropriate for our 7 year old so we switched out for a game that we felt more comfortable with him playing.

I am 60 years old and have been video gaming since the first days of Intellivision, Atari and Playstation. With that being said, I grew up watching John Wayne and Clint Eastwood. I love Westerns and always will. This game is truly the best game that I have played thus far and my all time favorite. Rock Star and Naughty Dog are the top two gaming companies in my opinion. I am playing on Xbox X and a 55" 4K TV the graphics set the bar and are just second to none. The music is well thought out and perfect for the era. The towns and scenery are just plain epic. You can get caught up in the scenery just looking around with the binoculars. There is something for everyone here from bustling St. Dennis to the Grizzly Mountains. Sure it takes a bit to get from point A to point B, but then again it did in those days too. I usually get side tracked hunting varmints or big game or stop and fish. Both activities are well thought out and so realistic, There are so many activities to do and sets to collect you will be playing this game for a very long time. There are many humorous adventures too. Like the first time I went up to a horse that I did not first make up to. I quickly got kicked across the stable. Or the time I hit the wrong button and punched my horse Pecos. He quickly turned around and kicked me a good 10 feet. Or the time a billy goat head butted me and knocked me down. Or the first time I tried roping a wild horse. I managed to finally catch up and rope him alongside a moving train; only to have him tumble and the train run him over dead. Hah! I think you get the picture. Let me say this game may not be for all. I have two sons, 16 and 22, both have watched me play. Neither are interested in playing the game one bit. They are from the fast paced CoD crowd. If I were to pick one fault with the game, it would be the save system. I have saved game play and when loaded I find myself in a different location. Also when starting a mission, it would be nice to make a save so if you mess up, you could go back to that save to try it again. For instance, I shot Flaco the gunslinger. He fell face down outside his cabin. Now you are supposed to take his picture to prove you shot him. I could not as the picture would not show his face. I tried and tried so many ways. I finally found if I walked thru him it disturbed his body a bit. After walking thru him about 25 times his face was exposed. You can replay missions, but you have to start from their check point. In this case I could not start the mission over as it wasn't complete. I would have had to go back to the previous day. If you travel far, you may need to do that all over again. This is a minor complaint though. I still feel RDR2 should be and will be GOTY . If you enjoy role playing games, this is a must have game.

spent hours just riding around trying to find the next challenge...

Stop sending chance to win gift card by writing a review

Boring game played forn2 days and couldnt stand the hand holding and slow movement speed feels clumsy and clunky

This game is so slow and boring...I don’t understand what all the hype is about

I would expect more of a challenge for these new games. He already loaned it out because he finished it.

Just not a game for me, unfortunately. No doubt this game is well made, but the amount of "realism" it hammers in is over the top to the point it hinders the experience of playing the game. Some actions are just a nuisance, without any apparent cohesive game design reason for the game existing that way - it just all seems to be for the sake of realism.

I usually can’t get past the first challenge on these games but so far im doing ok on this one

Great game, but the fair rating is for the price. Could have been a better Black Friday price.

The game was pretty much a horse simulator nothing but walking and petting a horse foe hours

this game is extremely violent and to much bad language

The action was repetitive and I returned the game for store credit.

It’s cheaper at amazon so it’s not a good buy check amazon

You walk around, murder wild life and cook it. Not my cup of tea.

Have not seen him play it yet, but waiting for birthday.

It's an ok FPS but the storyline moves incredibly slow.

Great game just the game play itself is a little slow

Not playing a game to chop wood and brush my horse