Customer Ratings & Reviews

Overall, ok. If your missing an elite controller stick or it's damaged, decent replacement. My biggest issue is the lack of quality on the thumb pads. After a handful of hours, the finish/rubber (not sure which) starts coming off almost like eraser dust on the controller. Hoped for a high end product from scuff, but got average.

Way much better than factory one and better quality.

Customize your performance by choosing from a range of thumbstick shapes and lengths. A domed design helps you make smoother, more precise aim adjustments, perfect for tracking targets or fine-tuning long-range shots. A concave stick gives your thumb a secure spot to stay centered, helping with faster movements and quick directional changes. Adjust height to boost precision for sniping or lower it for quicker, twitch-based movement.

I have been a huge fan of the Scuf thumbsticks for the elite series controller. They provide superior grip as compared to the original sticks. My only issue is that if you grip your controller hard, the sticks can wear down quicker over time. But if you have issues with thumbs slipping off the sticks, these are the way to go

Great grip and comfort, doesnt last long though. Bought these before and they are wore down to the metal in less than a year

They feel a little more rubbery / grippy compared to the stock thumbsticks for the elite controller 2. Still prefer the original thumbstick feel but these are pretty good considering the price and availability.

I bought these because I had read reviews and the extra sticky texture sounded great. I had them for about a month and one of the thumbsticks looks like it melted almost. It just completely lost its shape and turned into a glob of goo on top of the stick. I liked them but two months is not enough use to justify spending money on them again.

Overall great product , need to be more durable over time tear apart to fast , 2 months max ...

Came in good packaging and very promtply. They are easy to install and feel great. Alot better than the original thumbsticks on my elite pro controller

The fact that it comes with different sizes is a plus. It can adjust to my sons preference and it can also act as a spare.

these are great when they are new, depending on your level of use they seem to wear out fairly fast.

The Triggers are WAY too small and cramped, often leading to hitting Both triggers on respected sides. The Sticks don't fit snug at all. They feel Loose. Came advertised by every Site as "What Pro Gamers Use" but I highly doubt that now

Good replacement for original factory sticks. A little more dense, less rubbery feeling. Definitely would recommend.

the confort is great, but after a few months these wear off and start to peel apart. i would say i play a bit more than your average gamer so these might last longer with normal gamers. good thing is these are cheap(er), so you can always puchase more if needed.

A great spare for my Xbox Elite 2 controller. Grips are useful and comfort is above average.

these are great need replacement for the controller and they are want i wanted.

The thumbsticks work great and feel great, I just wish there was an option for a short domed option instead of only concave options

I purchased the 1st Gen scuf thumb sticks [white tipped] and they lasted about 18 months of abuse. I purchased these to replace the very abused ones. The thumb sticks look and feel better quality. And work as intended.

Not that great unless you need new thumbsticks, even then I’d get the Microsoft version of them anyway.

only had them since jan 23 2025 and they falling apart already 9-1-2025