Pros
Appealing design
Very clean setup with minimal wires
Nicely balance built-in speaker
Compact size
Capable Core i series desktop processor
Enough memory for all but the most demanding tasks
HDMI and Displayport
Dual monitor capable
USB-C for the future
Includes wireless keyboard and mouse
Multiple microphones for Cortana
Cons
Traditional hard drive
Massive power brick with proprietary plug
Difficult to upgrade hardware
Doesn’t fully take advantage of new technology in Windows 10
Keyboard can miss keys with faster typing speeds
Keyboard is a bit cramped
Mouse feels sticky and clicks require too much effort
Hard drive and fan can be a bit noisy for some
With regular box PCs becoming less popular, many companies are looking to change the definition of computer. HP is looking to take the standard drab looking computer case and turn it into something attractive you don’t mind having on a desk and it looks like they have succeeded. A nice feature for those looking to reduce clutter is the using HDMI and DisplayPort for monitors means smaller cords. Combine that with a built-in speaker and included wireless mouse and keyboard and the clutter is almost nonexistent. Just be prepared to find a place to fput the extremely large power brick.
I have enjoyed having a much neater desk, and more space. The built is speaker has a good range for a computer in this price level. It is listed as a 360-degree speaker but you will still notice exactly where the sound comes from. Keeping the sleekness in mind, the other option would have been monitor speakers which don’t have the range of the one in the tower. A built-in tower speaker is a good compromise. Of course, it doesn’t have tonal range or bass for audiophiles but for most people it has a pleasing range. If you want separate speakers, you would either use the front stereo jack, an HDMI audio extractor, or USB sound card. However; this does seem defeat the purpose of this design. Another possible problem with separate speakers could be the extra microphones tuned for use with Cortana. They work very well to understand commands given combined with the built-in speaker, but I suspect separate speakers would defeat this tuning. I can walk in the office and call Cortana without touching the computer to start up music, get the weather, or get the news. The experience has been more enjoyable than expected.
The included keyboard and mouse are adequate. If you have a lower typing speed you will likely find it works just fine. If you type faster, you might notice this keyboard will tend to miss keystrokes unless you bang on them hard. The mouse is adequate for this price point. It is ambidextrous and neutral. It feels a little sticky on a mousepad and the buttons require a more firm click than a higher end unit, but for the package deal it is appropriate. The wheel on the mouse is surprisingly good.
This Wave, being the lower end model, comes only with integrated graphics. It works good for regular tasks and casual gaming. If you need more horsepower, there is an upgraded model with a separate graphics card. Neither is intended for hardcore gamers or people who like to customize.
The one thing that surprised me about this design is that it a modern design with good specs in most places but includes an Achilles heel. With such a modern design, it has a standard hard drive. Hybrid drives are not that much more expensive and SSDs have come down in price significantly. It seems odd that this modern system uses an old school hard drive. This could be a blazing fast system with an SSD but the traditional hard drive crunching comes up often sounding like an old computer. Installing an HP printer on other modern computers takes no more than about 8 minutes. This system took 45 minutes to install one and 25 to install the other. In modern times, this feels like an eternity. The higher end model that includes an SSD likely doesn’t exhibit this issue but it is surprising they didn’t address this across the board.
This system is intended to be displayed and out in the open, likely on the desk. This is where the choice of a traditional hard drive is also quite odd. Old hard drives make a distinct sound that sound somewhat like crunching. When you place this computer out for display on a desk or shelf, it amplifies that sound taking away from the overall experience. Another noise of note is the case fan can be heard as what can be best described as a faint purring sound. The fan can get very loud at initial startup. So far, even during heavy usage it has not needed to run at full speed. Overall, the regular sounds are not overly intrusive but do take away from what could be a more refined experience. I am extremely picky about sound so the vast majority of people will never notice. For those like me, you will still be ok but you know what to expect.
If you have owned other HP computers, you will know that they usually come preloaded with software of questionable use. Although this system is no exception, the software is easily removed. Oddly what seems to be missing and would be useful is a hardware diagnostics. Other HP systems I have had included robust diagnostics to check everything in the event strange things started occurring with the computer. I have searched everywhere, including on startup, and can find none. Another small misstep is that HP didn’t take advantage of the advanced technology of Windows 10. Instead of promoting the games included in the store that work quite well, they preinstalled WildTangent games which are full of advertisements and require managing a separate account. The system applications, while updated in style, are still traditional applications meaning you must manually update them and address them as well. It is a shame they weren’t redesigned as apps that could be automatically maintained by Windows and updated without fuss. On a more advanced note, it would have been nice to see HP take advantage of a new technology in Windows which would have allowed the system to be restored via the web if needed. Currently, the only way to reinstall Windows is via the information on the hard drive. Windows 10 has a new recovery system that HP could have used in the event of failure, for whatever reason, the system could be restored via an automatic download from HP very easily. This could have further enhanced the customer experience but it was nowhere to be found.
Overall, the HP Wave is a very nice system with a modern design. With some minor adjustments, such as using an SSD in all models and modernizing the apps, this could have been a near perfect system. It most certainly feels like an HP system, but it feels like they have improved the design while keeping prices manageable. The system is designed well overall and can be a nice upgrade for someone needing a new system. It would be nice to see HP will make some minor tweaks with the next generation of what is already a very nice new design. Until then, the current HP Wave a very capable and elegantly designed desktop computer.