This is what great movie making is about; taking a simple story and idea, combining it with great acting, resulting in a captivating result. Despite it being Robert Redford, it took only minutes to 'forget' that it was him; the story was simple, not complex, but totally captivating from the start to end, which left you guessing right up to the last minute... This will be timeless; it needs no complex dialog, no special effects, no hot women, no stupid unbelievable plots or stunts...its a story that could touch any of us, and one that touches on experiences, feelings and emotions we should all recognize. It's a shame that such a film was passed over by this seasons awards, but I can see why Mr Redford chose to do this, and he gave a masterful performance, so much so, it did not appear as such.

This film may not be for everyone, but I found it fascinating. There is practically no dialog, but I think there is little reason for complaint on that score, as it is a one character movie and the situation needs no explanation. Robert Redford is remarkable in conveying desperation and ingenuity. Definitely a film worth seeing if you want something different and thought provoking.

Overhyped, yet overlooked is what Id say about this film. It seems as though this movie was designed in a Cast Away style to be a performance showcase for a actor. The fact the actor is the older Robert Redford I think that that alone makes the film stand out on its own. Contrived conception aside you can't deny Redford's ability and talent. Still its a good hour and a half watch.

I really liked the movie! I love movies and have always liked Robert Redford. The photography is top notch and the sound is fantastic. For only having one person in the movie it kept me on the edge of my seat for the whole time, without explosions and car chases. The only complaint was I wanted to know more backstory. This movie is not for everyone but is a subtle character study.

In the defining performance of his later career, Robert Redford thrills in this captivating story about an ordinary man's fight to survive against the treacherous seas. Brilliantly directed by JC Chandor, this drama is presented in low-dialogue naturalism, and it's atmospheric thrills and dry humor make it one of the most memorable survival films to date.