I am a diehard Star Trek fan who grew up watching the Original series in syndication. The new movies are okay. Chris Pine actually has developed into a fairly decent Kirk. I have a lot of complaints with each of these movies, but overall I think they are decent and entertaining. My favorite is Star Trek Into Darkness. While I wish they didn't try and re-tred Khan's story, if you ignore that point (and his magical fountain-of-youth blood) that movie is actually quite solid. And this collection is the only way to get all the extra bonus material that was included with retailer-specific bluray releases.

I had my doubts, but these first two films set in an alternate timeline are fun to watch over and over again. As a fan of all Star Trek shows and movies, I treat these Kelvin timeline films as “What ifs...”, and enjoy them in that way.

I got this originally from my local library and like the behind the scenes that came with the movies.

This was released as an apology to serious Trekkies who practically rioted online over Paramount's parceling out of special features on individual releases across vendors. And then what did they do on Star Trek Beyond? Parceled them out again! But whatever. As a product unto itself it's a great little set. But the repackaged version of this set is superior. Sleeker thinner case. The first release (which I have) is unnecessarily space consuming.

I'm giving this 4 out of 5 stars for a couple reasons. The packaging is really bad for this and I know that's a minor complaint. The main thing is that they are forcing us to rebuy the first movie which is already identical to what is included in this set. It was really only necessary to re-release the first movie with the IMAX and all the special features. Overall though, I say this is great for people that didn't previously own either of the movies. Just don't expect my for the packaging. It's quite flimsy.