Customer Ratings & Reviews

Overall, ok. If your missing an elite controller stick or it's damaged, decent replacement. My biggest issue is the lack of quality on the thumb pads. After a handful of hours, the finish/rubber (not sure which) starts coming off almost like eraser dust on the controller. Hoped for a high end product from scuff, but got average.

Very good grip compared to original thumbsticks would recommend to anyone and buy again! Thin sticks lasted about a year before the grip became wore down and not as good by still better than original thin sticks!

[Employee of bestbuy] I bought these because I had read reviews and the extra sticky texture sounded great. I had them for about a month and one of the thumbsticks looks like it melted almost. It just completely lost its shape and turned into a glob of goo on top of the stick. I liked them but two months is not enough use to justify spending money on them again.

Came in good packaging and very promtply. They are easy to install and feel great. Alot better than the original thumbsticks on my elite pro controller

A great spare for my Xbox Elite 2 controller. Grips are useful and comfort is above average.

Not nearly as good as the original sticks which came with the Elite series 2. Low grip and feel like a much cheaper product.

Have purchased these twice and you only get about 10 hours of game time before they start to break down and become unusable. The firm rubber becomes gum like then fall apart completely.

They are good grips. The regular Xbox grips handle my sweaty hands better though. As far as grip and handle they are great, I just feel my sweat under my thumbs more with this product than the elite series two grips.

Very cheaply made the red looks almost transparent. For 19.99 no padles or anything.wish they had the special edition like gears of war or Halo.

They wear down a lot quicker then the ones that come with your elite controller. Ended up going back to the originals.

We bought these the same day I bought the SCUF paddles and Elite 2 controller. The controller and paddles are great but these are junk. I have moderate usage on my Xbox One X because I have other responsibilities and cannot play all day. With that said, these do not hold up to moderate usage. They might work if you’re extremely gentle or only play an hour a week of games or less. I use the taller domed one on my right joystick and a shorter concave for the left joystick. Both of the concave short ones are ruined. With usage they get warm and they deform. I have not wrecked the domed stick yet but it is showing some signs of deformation. The concave ones have gotten to the point where the metal underneath is poking through. The ONLY positive to these which is also their biggest negative is that they are soft. They don’t hold up. I would not buy these again. I will recommend the SCUF paddles if you’re an FPS player and don’t like the Microsoft style.

They get dirty and worm out quickly. Not worth it at all

These are good thumbtacks but I really didn't notice much difference from elite 2 thumbsticks.

Absolutely not worth the purchase. Why is one of them a creamy white while the rest is a regular white? The magnet sucks. The bar looks awkward on the controller as if it wasn't suppose to be there.

I wish I can use it on all of my controllers but it’s pretty cool and comfortable

These are incredible. But over time they literally just blemish away like a floor Mat in a car. The more you use it the more they wear away. Luckily they are cheap and in expensive so I really like them because they are so soft and gripy.

I bought these because I didn't know the elite comes with additional swappable thumbsticks. I don't find the Scuf kit to be worth it, since the only real unique thumbstick is the domed stick. I am returning. These would be great to replace broken or worn out elite thumbsticks, though.

Pack of 4 thumbsticks was 2 different colors. 2 were bright white as expected, other 2 have a yellow tinge to them

Good as a replacement, not different enough to the pack-in Elite 2 to justify a stand-alone purchase but are fine if you lost one.

Nice does what its supposed to do no problems and looks nice.