Customer Ratings & Reviews

What can I say that hasn't been said everywhere else? A Perfect Circle is one of my favorite projects to come from Maynard, and this CD is a great compilation of the best songs from the three major albums APC released. The inclusion of a nice APC t-shirt for a Best Buy exclusive for about $15 more than the CD on it's own is a very fair value and gives me another way to show off my enjoyment of what I consider one of the best singer/song writers of my generation.

I am a big fan of A PERFECT CIRCLE. I originally did not plan on buying this album as it only has 1 new song on it and I already own every other album from this band. However, the value made it worthwhile for the Tshirt alone! So getting the album was an added bonus. It is a great collection of some of the best A PERFECT CIRCLE songs, has 1 new stuido track, plus 3 live songs I had not heard before. Plus came with the Tshirt! So it was definitely worth it for me! But if u want new material, don't expect much from this.

This is pretty much your run of the mill greatest hits album. The plus side is there is 1 new song and 3 live songs on the deluxe edition. Most fans will already have 98 percent of the music included in this and just buy the new track digitally. But if u are a completeist then get the deluxe edition with the shirt.

The good of this greatest hits, it has almost great song from them. The bad. Only has one new song and doesn't have the remix version of the outsider song.

This compilation does a great job gathering the best work of A Perfect Circle, which already is a lot to say. All the classics are included plus some nice extra not-so-obvious choices. The only problem is that only one new song is included (plus a few live versions of older songs), which makes this album not a great value for the price if you already have their studio albums. The Best Buy limited edition comes with a pretty cool t-shirt that makes a nice addition to the package.

If you don't have any of their albums yet, this would be one to get. It's a great sampling of everything the band has to offer, and if you are a long time fan, it's also a winner cause it has the only new song they have released lately.

I bought the set that came with the t-shirt. The shirt wasn't much, thin, plain logo, whatever, but this was for the music. The music is great, and even a tiny bit of new APC is always welcome. Highly recommended.

Best collection ever! Maynard is king! Got this as a present from my husband. The t shirt is awesome!!!!!

it's a perfect circle the sound is great the live takes are perfectly mixed and the cd flows perfect.

Great price $15.99 free shirt I just wanted the shirt I already had the CDs separately

This is great for the music collector. It's nice to have in the music "library".

My kind of music. I listen to it everyday while playing my games.

A Perfect Circle is great live. Came with a T-shirt

Just 2 great cd's from start to end & the only @ Best Buy T-shirt made it even better!!

I was so excited for this.. I can not express the joy this brings me,,,