Customer Ratings & Reviews

If you are a true Pink Floyd fan you will really love this. The original album doesn't sound too different from the 91' or the "Oh By The Way" Box set editions, but there are things here and there that you notice that are different so it was OK. The live CD along with the unreleased content is of great quality, and its amazing to hear the "rough" performances of Sheep (Raving and Drooling) and Dogs (You've Gotta Be Crazy). The Wine Glasses song from household projects sounds great, and the alternate version of Have A Cigar is great too... Its interesting to hear the difference between Roy Harper and Roger Waters on the song and you get the sense of understanding as to why they chose someone else... but it is good. And the alt. version of WYWH is alright, I just think the fiddle in the background sends it too far and makes it too complicated.. But otherwise everything is great and you can really experience Pink Floyd like you have never before!

This is one of the greatest albums of all time. The extra live and studio bonus content in this release makes it a must have!