Skip to contentGo to Product Search
Main Content
Skip to contentGo to Product Search
Main Content
Categories & Filters
Best Buy

/

all video games

/

physical video games

Creepy Puzzle Games

Find creepy puzzle games that combine brain-teasing challenges with an eerie atmosphere. Compare game descriptions for the balance of mystery, suspense, and puzzle difficulty you prefer, and check age recommendations and content details to choose an experience that suits your comfort level.

Read More
Results
Main Results

  1. Until Dawn - PlayStation Hits Standard Edition - PlayStation 4

    SKU: JXHQ3JVHZF

    Great horror game...Excellent game.. horror, best game of 2015. Ps4 i love it...Best game...Has been one of the best games ! I absolutely love playing it.

    Product Description

    A cinematic horror adventure where your choices determine the fate of eight friends on a terrifying mountain retreat.
    See all Physical Video Games
    Your price for this item is $19.99

  2. Selects: Luigi's Mansion: Dark Moon - Nintendo 3DS

    SKU: J7GSL4HQR8

    Product Description

    A thrilling adventure game where you capture ghosts and solve puzzles using inventive gadgets in haunted mansions.
    See all Physical Video Games
    Your price for this item is $44.99

  3. UNDERTALE - Nintendo Switch [Digital]

    SKU: JCQ6HSGZ73

    Love Undertale!...love it!

    Product Description

    An engaging role-playing adventure with player-driven choices, memorable music, and unique bullet-dodging gameplay.
    See all Game Downloads
    Your price for this item is $14.99

  4. Paranormal Activity: The Lost Soul - PlayStation 5, PlayStation 4

    SKU: JXHQ3JVXJV

    Product Description

    A chilling horror game where you explore a haunted house with only a flashlight and your wits.
    See all Physical Video Games
    Your price for this item is $19.99

  5. Luigi's Mansion - Nintendo 3DS

    SKU: J7GSL4HTCH

    Product Description

    A thrilling action-adventure where you capture ghosts and solve puzzles using a vacuum on Nintendo 3DS.
    See all Physical Video Games
    Your price for this item is $59.99

  6. Hello Neighbor - XBOX One, Windows [Digital]

    SKU: JCQ6HY889X

    Product Description

    A suspenseful stealth horror game where advanced AI adapts to your every move on Xbox One and Windows.
    See all Game Downloads
    Your price for this item is $29.99

  7. The Inpatient - PlayStation 4

    SKU: JXHQ3JFH5V

    Product Description

    An immersive VR-compatible horror game where your choices determine the fate of an amnesiac patient.
    See all Physical Video Games
    Your price for this item is $19.99

  8. Hello Neighbor: Hide & Seek - XBOX One

    SKU: J3RPSS693G

    Product Description

    A suspenseful single-player horror game where adaptive AI challenges you to uncover mysterious neighborhood secrets.
    See all Physical Video Games
    Your price for this item is $28.79

  9. Hello Neighbor: Hide & Seek - PlayStation 4

    SKU: J3RPSS69XW

    Product Description

    A stealth horror game where you outsmart your neighbor in a suspenseful game of hide and seek.
    See all Physical Video Games
    Your price for this item is $21.99

  10. Until Dawn – PS5 - PlayStation 5

    SKU: JXHQ3CCYCX

    Best horror game...Love the action and suspense of the entire game. Keeps you on your toes....Love the remake!...Supermassives best game!

    Product Description

    An enhanced horror adventure where your choices determine survival during a terrifying mountain retreat on PS5.
    See all Physical Video Games
    Your price for this item is $59.99

  11. Gorogoa Standard Edition - Nintendo Switch

    SKU: J3RPRPK6ZF

    Product Description

    An imaginative hand-drawn puzzle adventure featuring interactive storytelling and satisfying gameplay for Nintendo Switch.
    See all Physical Video Games
    Your price for this item is $69.97

  12. Little Nightmares Complete Edition - Nintendo Switch [Digital]

    SKU: JCQ6HP8JKF

    best horror puzzle platformer...MY NEW FAVORITE GAME. this game made me scream. in both fear and frustration. i love it so much. i can...I love it. Such a fun game. I can easily play for hours

    Product Description

    An immersive digital collection featuring both original and bonus adventures with a hauntingly atmospheric soundtrack.
    See all Game Downloads
    Your price for this item is $29.99

  13. Little Nightmares II - Nintendo Switch, Nintendo Switch Lite [Digital]

    SKU: JCQ6HQ2X7T

    My kids love this. It’s creepy, and entertaining....Great game....Best scary game

    Product Description

    A suspenseful platformer adventure where you guide Mono and Six through eerie puzzles and haunting threats.
    See all Game Downloads
    Your price for this item is $29.99

  14. Spirit Hunter: NG Standard Edition - Nintendo Switch

    SKU: J3R45RXPKX

    Product Description

    An action-horror adventure where your choices determine survival against terrifying spirits, featuring detailed graphics.
    See all Physical Video Games
    Your price for this item is $39.99

  15. Night in the Woods - Nintendo Switch [Digital]

    SKU: JCQ6HPJ9GY

    Love this game, one of the best, not too hard of a puzzle game. Beautiful visuals...Love the art, interesting story...This is a very fun, no pressure game that has great artwork and music!

    Product Description

    An atmospheric action-adventure platformer exploring friendship and mystery in a nostalgic, story-rich digital experience.
    See all Game Downloads
    Your price for this item is $19.99

  16. Goosebumps: Terror in Little Creek - Nintendo Switch

    SKU: J3GW3LGL9S

    We love goosebumps and this game is awesome....Compared to the click and point games of goosebumps this one takes the cake. 100% love it for young adventurers...Great game...Great game, fun to play. Great...

    Product Description

    A spooky horror puzzle adventure where you solve mysteries and evade monsters in a haunted town.
    See all Physical Video Games
    Your price for this item is $29.99

  17. Monstrum - PlayStation 5, PlayStation 4

    SKU: J3RQ3LTY5Z

    Product Description

    A suspenseful survival horror game with procedurally-generated levels, permadeath, and unpredictable AI predators.
    See all Physical Video Games
    Your price for this item is $34.99
    Save $3
    The previous price was $37.99

  18. White Day: A Labyrinth Named School - Nintendo Switch, Nintendo Switch Lite

    SKU: J3L9XJKYFZ

    Product Description

    A tense, stealth-based Korean horror game featuring branching stories, multiple endings, and white-themed visuals.
    See all Physical Video Games
    Your price for this item is $31.99

  19. The Room - Nintendo Switch [Digital]

    SKU: JCQ6HSK8CH

    Best Puzzle Game...I have always loved puzzle games and this is still the best!...Love this game,super fun yet it test your skills.I can play for hours trying to solve puzzles.

    Product Description

    A digital puzzle adventure where you solve intricate mysteries using your wits on Nintendo Switch.
    See all Game Downloads
    Your price for this item is $9.99

  20. Little Nightmares Standard Edition - XBOX One [Digital]

    SKU: JCQ6Q452PR

    I love this game and can't wait for the second one....I bought this game for my grandsons they love playing it.

    Product Description

    A dark, whimsical action-adventure game where you help Six escape a mysterious vessel filled with danger.
    See all Game Downloads
    Your price for this item is $19.99

  21. Goosebumps: Terror in Little Creek - PlayStation 5

    SKU: J3GW3LGL62

    Product Description

    A spooky horror-puzzle adventure where you solve mysteries and evade monsters in a haunted town.
    See all Physical Video Games
    Your price for this item is $36.19

  22. Monstrum - XBOX One

    SKU: J3RQ3LTYFJ

    Product Description

    A procedurally-generated survival horror game with permadeath and AI predators set on a derelict cargo ship.
    See all Physical Video Games
    Your price for this item is $34.99
    Save $3
    The previous price was $37.99

  23. Gorogoa - Nintendo Switch [Digital]

    SKU: JCQ6HSYX4S

    Product Description

    A hand-drawn digital puzzle adventure featuring clever panel-arranging challenges and immersive, imaginative gameplay.
    See all Game Downloads
    Your price for this item is $14.99

  24. Avalon Hill - Betrayal at House on the Hill

    SKU: CG477KSSK6

    Great...Great for game nights with older kids or even an adult gathering . I had a blast playing ....I really love this game.

    Product Description

    An immersive cooperative board game featuring 50 chilling haunts, modular rooms, and a hidden traitor twist.
    See all Board Games
    Your price for this item is $61.78
1-18 of 176 items
0 items

Creepy puzzle games combine the satisfaction of solving a mystery with the suspense of exploring somewhere that feels unsettling. Instead of relying entirely on combat, these atmospheric games can challenge you to decipher coded messages, connect scattered clues, unlock hidden passages, and figure out how unfamiliar mechanisms work. A flickering light, a distant sound, or an object that seems out of place may be part of the puzzle—or a reason to think twice before opening the next door. Horror puzzle games span a range of styles, from eerie point-and-click adventures and haunted-house mysteries to escape room games with tense countdowns. Environmental storytelling can make exploration especially rewarding, as notes, photographs, and changes in your surroundings gradually reveal what happened. If you enjoy piecing together a story rather than having every answer explained immediately, look for mystery puzzle games that emphasize observation, logical thinking, and discovery alongside their scares. Finding the right scary puzzle game starts with deciding how much tension you want between each breakthrough. For a slower-paced experience, look for descriptions that emphasize exploration, intricate riddles, and psychological suspense; if you prefer more pressure, consider games that combine puzzle-solving with pursuit sequences, survival mechanics, or limited resources. Check the ESRB rating and content descriptors to help distinguish a spooky adventure from a more intense horror experience, and review whether the gameplay includes jump scares, graphic imagery, or disturbing themes. Platform compatibility, control options, and system requirements also matter, particularly when choosing PC puzzle games or comparing console versions. Features such as adjustable difficulty, optional hints, readable subtitles, and flexible save systems can help you find an experience that suits your play style, so check individual game details for availability. Whether you prefer unraveling a supernatural mystery on your own or sharing the discoveries in a cooperative puzzle game, focus on the balance of atmosphere, challenge, and storytelling that will keep you curious about the next clue.

Best Sellers

Related Pages

FAQ

Creepy puzzle games combine brainteasers with eerie settings, mysterious stories, and unsettling sound design. Gameplay often centers on investigating your surroundings, finding clues, and solving puzzles to uncover what happened or reach a new area.

Common challenges include decoding messages, identifying patterns, combining objects, and unlocking doors with hidden clues. Some games also feature environmental puzzles, where lighting, perspective, or objects in the scene reveal the solution.

Creepy puzzle games typically emphasize observation, deduction, and exploration, while survival horror often places more emphasis on managing resources and confronting or avoiding threats. The genres can overlap, so a horror puzzle game may also include chase sequences or combat.

Many creepy puzzle games weave their puzzles into a larger mystery. You might piece together the story through notes, recordings, character conversations, or details in the environment, with each solved puzzle revealing more of the narrative.

Some creepy puzzle games offer cooperative multiplayer, allowing players to share clues and work through challenges together. Others are single-player experiences, so check the supported game modes and whether multiplayer uses local play or an online connection.

Sign in or Create Account

Get the latest deals and more.

Best Buy appLearn more
Share on YouTubeShare on InstagramShare on TikTokShare on FacebookShare on PinterestShare on X
Best Buy Canada
AccessibilityTerms & ConditionsPrivacyInterest-Based AdsState Privacy RightsHealth Data PrivacyDo Not Sell/Share My Personal InformationLimit Use of My Sensitive Personal InformationTargeted Advertising Opt OutCA Supply Chain Transparency Act
In-store pricing may vary. Prices and offers are subject to change. © 2026 Best Buy. All rights reserved. BEST BUY, the BEST BUY logo, the tag design, and MY BEST BUY are trademarks of Best Buy and its affiliated companies.
Sign in or Create Account

Get the latest deals and more.

Best Buy appLearn more
Share on YouTubeShare on InstagramShare on TikTokShare on FacebookShare on PinterestShare on X
Best Buy Canada

In-store pricing may vary. Prices and offers are subject to change. © 2026 Best Buy. All rights reserved. BEST BUY, the BEST BUY logo, the tag design, and MY BEST BUY are trademarks of Best Buy and its affiliated companies.