A:AnswerThe GeekSquad would try to fix them first and not until all the options have been tried they would let you know what your options are. If they can't fix it and still under warranty you should be able to get another pair. Good Luck
A:AnswerNo I really don't think so, without police report there is know way for Apple care + to know if there is truth to that without you being able to show headphone . I say that only because in order to replace and send you a new pair . u have to send back old ones . more like a swap out old for new ....
A:AnswerYou bought regular headphone not wireless charging one you have to make sure that they say wireless charging and if you have the first generation of AirPods they don’t have wireless charging
A:AnswerChoose the coverage that’s right for you.
AppleCare+
AppleCare+ for iPhone includes up to two incidents of accidental damage coverage every 24 months.3 Each incident is subject to the service fees listed below, plus applicable tax. In addition, you’ll get Express Replacement Service4 and 24/7 priority access to Apple experts by chat or phone.2
AppleCare+ with Theft and Loss
AppleCare+ with Theft and Loss includes up to two incidents of accidental damage, theft, or loss coverage every 24 months.3 Each incident is subject to the deductibles listed below. In addition, you’ll get Express Replacement Service4 and 24/7 priority access to Apple experts by chat or phone.2
Theft and loss coverage requires you to have Find My iPhone enabled on your device at the time it is lost or stolen.5