A:Answer Hi Adie. Thanks for the great question! Whenever you do an exchange with your Geek Squad Protection, it actually uses it up. So more than likely, you purchased a new protection plan for the replacement headset. So, if this were to happen again, it would utilize the new plan. I hope this makes sense! If you have any other questions or need further clarification, I'd recommend reaching out to your local Best Buy store. You can find information about your local store at www.bestbuy.com/storelocator.