Most Reliable Toaster
Best Buy customers often prefer the following products when searching for Most Reliable Toaster.
Toasters are a kitchen staple, but they're also a great place to save money and energy by buying a more reliable model. You need a toaster that can toast bread, bagels, and English muffins evenly and consistently, so you can enjoy the same great-tasting breakfast every time. Browse the top-ranked list of the most reliable toasters below along with associated reviews and opinions.
Breville - Smart Oven Air Fryer Compact, 0.5 Cubic Feet Toaster Oven - Brushed Stainless Steel
Model: BOV680BSS1BUC1SKU: 6617568Top comment"Air fryer/toaster oven...Air fryer option works great and toaster option toasts the bread evenly. Takes up less space on the counter too. ...Extremely Reliable...This is the best toaster oven I have ever used. The amount of settings there are gives you a variety of options for things you can cook in it. "
See all customer reviewsSee all Toaster OvensProduct Description
The Smart Oven Air Fryer Compact offers 10 smart functions including 5 air fry & 5 smart oven favorites to deliver maximum performance and versatility. Enjoy the confidence of cooking with Breville+. The full experience is free when you register your oven.Top comment"Air fryer/toaster oven...Air fryer option works great and toaster option toasts the bread evenly. Takes up less space on the counter too. ...Extremely Reliable...This is the best toaster oven I have ever used. The amount of settings there are gives you a variety of options for things you can cook in it. "
See all customer reviewsSee all Toaster OvensProduct Description
The Smart Oven Air Fryer Compact offers 10 smart functions including 5 air fry & 5 smart oven favorites to deliver maximum performance and versatility. Enjoy the confidence of cooking with Breville+. The full experience is free when you register your oven.See all Toaster OvensYour price for this item is $199.95The comparable value price is $249.95Select pickup
Select shipping
KitchenAid - 4-Slice Toaster with Illuminated Buttons - Onyx Black
Model: KMT4115OBSKU: 8812936Top comment"Good guy, fast toaster...Not anything crazy, but I am a "light tan" toaster, so I would have tan on one side, and hot, just starting to get stiff white bread on the other side. ...Great toaster...It's been awhile since I've owned a regular drop in toaster. I've had a toaster oven for about 7 years. "
See all customer reviewsSee all ToastersProduct Description
KitchenAid’s KMT4115OB 4-Slice Toaster, in onyx black, has dual independent controls and chrome buttons that glow with blue back-light illumination when in use. The extra-wide slots will accept the thickest bagels, breads, or pastries and the extra-deep, steel toasting cavity ensures even browning. The racks automatically adjust the slot width for thick or thin slices, keeping food upright for even toasting. When your food is ready, the manual high lift lever makes it easy to get it out of the toaster. Selecting the bagel toasting function reduces the power on one side of the heating elements by 50% to produce a better toasted bagel! Plus, the adjustable 5-shade setting ensures your food will pop up just the way you like it.Top comment"Good guy, fast toaster...Not anything crazy, but I am a "light tan" toaster, so I would have tan on one side, and hot, just starting to get stiff white bread on the other side. ...Great toaster...It's been awhile since I've owned a regular drop in toaster. I've had a toaster oven for about 7 years. "
See all customer reviewsSee all ToastersProduct Description
KitchenAid’s KMT4115OB 4-Slice Toaster, in onyx black, has dual independent controls and chrome buttons that glow with blue back-light illumination when in use. The extra-wide slots will accept the thickest bagels, breads, or pastries and the extra-deep, steel toasting cavity ensures even browning. The racks automatically adjust the slot width for thick or thin slices, keeping food upright for even toasting. When your food is ready, the manual high lift lever makes it easy to get it out of the toaster. Selecting the bagel toasting function reduces the power on one side of the heating elements by 50% to produce a better toasted bagel! Plus, the adjustable 5-shade setting ensures your food will pop up just the way you like it.See all ToastersYour price for this item is $94.99The comparable value price is $99.99Select pickup
Select shipping
KitchenAid - 4-Slice Toaster with Illuminated Buttons - Contour Silver
Model: KMT4115CUSKU: 8812854Top comment"Great Toaster...KitchenAid products are typically solid and reliable. this wide slot toaster does not disappoint. ...Overall a great toaster, cooks as outlined and is consistent. Only knock is that it takes up a lot of space on a counter vs. other toasters."
See all customer reviewsSee all ToastersProduct Description
KitchenAid’s KMT4115CU 4-Slice Toaster, in contour silver, has dual independent controls and chrome buttons that glow with blue back-light illumination when in use. The extra-wide slots will accept the thickest bagels, breads, or pastries and the extra-deep, steel toasting cavity ensures even browning. The racks automatically adjust the slot width for thick or thin slices, keeping food upright for even toasting. When your food is ready, the manual high lift lever makes it easy to get it out of the toaster. Selecting the bagel toasting function reduces the power on one side of the heating elements by 50% to produce a better toasted bagel! Plus, the adjustable 5-shade setting ensures your food will pop up just the way you like it.Top comment"Great Toaster...KitchenAid products are typically solid and reliable. this wide slot toaster does not disappoint. ...Overall a great toaster, cooks as outlined and is consistent. Only knock is that it takes up a lot of space on a counter vs. other toasters."
See all customer reviewsSee all ToastersProduct Description
KitchenAid’s KMT4115CU 4-Slice Toaster, in contour silver, has dual independent controls and chrome buttons that glow with blue back-light illumination when in use. The extra-wide slots will accept the thickest bagels, breads, or pastries and the extra-deep, steel toasting cavity ensures even browning. The racks automatically adjust the slot width for thick or thin slices, keeping food upright for even toasting. When your food is ready, the manual high lift lever makes it easy to get it out of the toaster. Selecting the bagel toasting function reduces the power on one side of the heating elements by 50% to produce a better toasted bagel! Plus, the adjustable 5-shade setting ensures your food will pop up just the way you like it.See all ToastersYour price for this item is $94.99The comparable value price is $99.99Select pickup
Select shipping
KitchenAid - 4-Slice Toaster with Illuminated Buttons - Empire Red
Model: KMT4115ERSKU: 8813104Top comment"Like the style and features of the toaster...So I checked out there toasters, which I am glad that I did . Very happy with my purchase. ...Favorite toaster ever!!...[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] This 4 slice toaster is by far the best toaster I have ever used. "
See all customer reviewsSee all ToastersProduct Description
KitchenAid’s KMT4115ER 4-Slice Toaster, in empire red, has dual independent controls and chrome buttons that glow with blue back-light illumination when in use. The extra-wide slots will accept the thickest bagels, breads, or pastries and the extra-deep, steel toasting cavity ensures even browning. The racks automatically adjust the slot width for thick or thin slices, keeping food upright for even toasting. When your food is ready, the manual high lift lever makes it easy to get it out of the toaster. Selecting the bagel toasting function reduces the power on one side of the heating elements by 50% to produce a better toasted bagel! Plus, the adjustable 5-shade setting ensures your food will pop up just the way you like it.Top comment"Like the style and features of the toaster...So I checked out there toasters, which I am glad that I did . Very happy with my purchase. ...Favorite toaster ever!!...[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] This 4 slice toaster is by far the best toaster I have ever used. "
See all customer reviewsSee all ToastersProduct Description
KitchenAid’s KMT4115ER 4-Slice Toaster, in empire red, has dual independent controls and chrome buttons that glow with blue back-light illumination when in use. The extra-wide slots will accept the thickest bagels, breads, or pastries and the extra-deep, steel toasting cavity ensures even browning. The racks automatically adjust the slot width for thick or thin slices, keeping food upright for even toasting. When your food is ready, the manual high lift lever makes it easy to get it out of the toaster. Selecting the bagel toasting function reduces the power on one side of the heating elements by 50% to produce a better toasted bagel! Plus, the adjustable 5-shade setting ensures your food will pop up just the way you like it.See all ToastersYour price for this item is $94.99The comparable value price is $99.99Select pickup
Select shipping
Cuisinart - Air Fryer 0.6 Cu. Ft. Toaster Oven with Grill - White
Model: TOA-70WNASSKU: 6620247See all Toaster OvensProduct Description
Cuisinart’s signature Air Fryer just got even better! In addition to Air Frying French fries, baking cookies or warming up your leftovers, now you can make even more delicious meals in your Cuisinart Air Fryer Toaster Oven with Grill! Sear steaks and vegetables on one side and griddle the perfect breakfast on the other with the new dual-sided grill and griddle plate. Bring next-generation cooking to your countertop with the spacious 8-function oven that makes cooking a feast for family and friends — or a simple snack for one — fun, fast, and easy!See all Toaster OvensProduct Description
Cuisinart’s signature Air Fryer just got even better! In addition to Air Frying French fries, baking cookies or warming up your leftovers, now you can make even more delicious meals in your Cuisinart Air Fryer Toaster Oven with Grill! Sear steaks and vegetables on one side and griddle the perfect breakfast on the other with the new dual-sided grill and griddle plate. Bring next-generation cooking to your countertop with the spacious 8-function oven that makes cooking a feast for family and friends — or a simple snack for one — fun, fast, and easy!See all Toaster OvensYour price for this item is $159.95The comparable value price is $219.95Select pickup
Select shipping
Cuisinart - Air Fryer 0.6 Cu. Ft. Toaster Oven with Grill - Black
Model: TOA-70BKSNASSKU: 6620248Top comment"It’s only weakness is the toaster function. Toasters are just faster and better for bread, muffins, bagels, etc. ...Greatvlittle toaster oven!...Excellent product. Easy to use, reliable ,easy to clean and a great addition to our home."
See all customer reviewsSee all Toaster OvensProduct Description
Cuisinart’s signature Air Fryer just got even better! In addition to Air Frying French fries, baking cookies or warming up your leftovers, now you can make even more delicious meals in your Cuisinart Air Fryer Toaster Oven with Grill! Sear steaks and vegetables on one side and griddle the perfect breakfast on the other with the new dual-sided grill and griddle plate. Bring next-generation cooking to your countertop with the spacious 8-function oven that makes cooking a feast for family and friends — or a simple snack for one — fun, fast, and easy!Top comment"It’s only weakness is the toaster function. Toasters are just faster and better for bread, muffins, bagels, etc. ...Greatvlittle toaster oven!...Excellent product. Easy to use, reliable ,easy to clean and a great addition to our home."
See all customer reviewsSee all Toaster OvensProduct Description
Cuisinart’s signature Air Fryer just got even better! In addition to Air Frying French fries, baking cookies or warming up your leftovers, now you can make even more delicious meals in your Cuisinart Air Fryer Toaster Oven with Grill! Sear steaks and vegetables on one side and griddle the perfect breakfast on the other with the new dual-sided grill and griddle plate. Bring next-generation cooking to your countertop with the spacious 8-function oven that makes cooking a feast for family and friends — or a simple snack for one — fun, fast, and easy!See all Toaster OvensYour price for this item is $159.95The comparable value price is $219.95Select pickup
Select shipping
KitchenAid - 4 Slice Programmable Toaster, 120V - Empire Red
Model: KMT4109ERSKU: 6637103Top comment"Reliable...[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] This is a reliable toaster that offers a lot of flexibility. ...[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] Good toaster, we like being able to do larger items."
See all customer reviewsSee all ToastersProduct Description
Make everyday simply delicious and easily toast your favorite breads, bagels and more with ease. This KitchenAid 4 Slice Toaster features extra-wide slots to toast a variety of shapes and sizes, including homemade or craft breads. For added convenience the adjustable shade control, from light to dark, ensures you'll have your toast just the way you like it, every time. It's built to last and the durable metal design adds style to your countertop.Top comment"Reliable...[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] This is a reliable toaster that offers a lot of flexibility. ...[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] Good toaster, we like being able to do larger items."
See all customer reviewsSee all ToastersProduct Description
Make everyday simply delicious and easily toast your favorite breads, bagels and more with ease. This KitchenAid 4 Slice Toaster features extra-wide slots to toast a variety of shapes and sizes, including homemade or craft breads. For added convenience the adjustable shade control, from light to dark, ensures you'll have your toast just the way you like it, every time. It's built to last and the durable metal design adds style to your countertop.See all ToastersYour price for this item is $179.99The comparable value price is $199.99Select pickup
Select shipping
Bella - 4-Slice Toaster - Blossom
Model: 35245-016ASKU: 6637332Top comment"This Bella Kitchenware 4-Slice Toaster truly does have wide slots that easily fit a sliced bagel. ...Loved this toaster!...Overall, the Bella PRO 4-Slice Toaster provides excellent value with its reliable performance and modern aesthetics, making it a great choice for everyday use."
See all customer reviewsSee all ToastersProduct Description
This bella 4-Slice Toaster combines traditional functionality with a sleek, modern design to perk up your kitchen counter. With extra-wide slots that accommodate a variety of bread types, including thick slices and bagels, this toaster is your new go-to. It ensures perfect, even browning thanks to precise 6-setting shade controls and has a Bagel preset for perfect toasting. It also includes a removable crumb tray for easy cleanup, auto centering guides for consistent results, and an anti-jam and auto-shutoff system for added safety.See all ToastersTop comment"This Bella Kitchenware 4-Slice Toaster truly does have wide slots that easily fit a sliced bagel. ...Loved this toaster!...Overall, the Bella PRO 4-Slice Toaster provides excellent value with its reliable performance and modern aesthetics, making it a great choice for everyday use."
See all customer reviewsSee all ToastersProduct Description
This bella 4-Slice Toaster combines traditional functionality with a sleek, modern design to perk up your kitchen counter. With extra-wide slots that accommodate a variety of bread types, including thick slices and bagels, this toaster is your new go-to. It ensures perfect, even browning thanks to precise 6-setting shade controls and has a Bagel preset for perfect toasting. It also includes a removable crumb tray for easy cleanup, auto centering guides for consistent results, and an anti-jam and auto-shutoff system for added safety.
Cuisinart - 4.5 qt Basket Air Fryer - Black Stainless Steel
Model: AIR-160NASSKU: 6643344See all Toaster OvensProduct Description
Prepare a variety of dishes, from quick snacks to hearty meals, effortlessly with the versatile Cuisinart 4.5-qt Basket Air Fryer. Air Advantage technology ensures healthier, crispy, and flavorful results every time. Featuring a large 8”x8” cooking surface area for more even cooking plus four cooking functions, a toss reminder, and a convenient viewing window, it simplifies air frying, roasting and baking. Four easy-to-use air fry presets takes the guesswork out of air frying your favorites.See all Toaster OvensProduct Description
Prepare a variety of dishes, from quick snacks to hearty meals, effortlessly with the versatile Cuisinart 4.5-qt Basket Air Fryer. Air Advantage technology ensures healthier, crispy, and flavorful results every time. Featuring a large 8”x8” cooking surface area for more even cooking plus four cooking functions, a toss reminder, and a convenient viewing window, it simplifies air frying, roasting and baking. Four easy-to-use air fry presets takes the guesswork out of air frying your favorites.See all Toaster OvensYour price for this item is $69.95The comparable value price is $119.95Select pickup
Select shipping
Bella - Fits-anywhere Kitchenware: 2-Slice Slim Toaster with Long Wide Slot - Oatmilk
Model: 35117-023ASKU: 6637250Top comment"Toaster...This toaster was cheap so I didn't think it would be good but it's one of the best toasters I've ever had!...Slim toaster...Great little toaster that fits in those tight little spaces where normal toasters just don’t fit."
See all customer reviewsSee all ToastersProduct Description
This bella Fits-anywhere Kitchenware 2-Slice Slim Toaster with Long Wide Slot won’t crowd the counter. With one long slot (instead of the traditional two) and a slim 3.58" profile, this toaster fits tight spaces and looks good while doing it. Plus, it serves up crisp toast in minutes. The slot fits two slices of bread side by side and is roomy enough for thick bagels, Texas-style toasts or even baguettes.See all ToastersTop comment"Toaster...This toaster was cheap so I didn't think it would be good but it's one of the best toasters I've ever had!...Slim toaster...Great little toaster that fits in those tight little spaces where normal toasters just don’t fit."
See all customer reviewsSee all ToastersProduct Description
This bella Fits-anywhere Kitchenware 2-Slice Slim Toaster with Long Wide Slot won’t crowd the counter. With one long slot (instead of the traditional two) and a slim 3.58" profile, this toaster fits tight spaces and looks good while doing it. Plus, it serves up crisp toast in minutes. The slot fits two slices of bread side by side and is roomy enough for thick bagels, Texas-style toasts or even baguettes.
Shopping ideas related to Most Reliable Toaster
- Best 4 Piece Toaster
"[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] Great toaster, love the temperature control and lift lever"
- Best 4 Slice Toaster
"[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] I received this 4-slice toaster as a Christmas gift from my daughter"
- Best Rated Toaster
"This is by far the best toaster over I have ever owned. The features are great"
- Compact 2-Slice Toaster
"Powerful cutting/carving performance in a compact size! Sturdy construction- ergonomic, balanced handle that makes quick work of turkey/ham/tenderloin carving and even slicing"