Appreciation EventEnds Sunday. Limited quantities. No rainchecks.Shop now

Skip to contentGo to Product Search
Main Content
Categories & Filters
Best Buy

/

small kitchen appliances

/

toaster ovens & toasters

/

toasters

Bagel Toasters

Toasters are a kitchen staple for anyone who likes to make their own toast. While some people prefer the simplicity of a two-slice toaster, others need four slots for their family's morning bagels and English muffins. Browse the top-ranked list of bagel toasters below along with associated reviews and opinions.

Read More
Results
Main Results

  1. Bella - 2-Slice Toaster - Plum

    SKU: J3P5RPJ9TX

    Best Toaster Ever, Love The Color, it Matches My Coffee Pot and Can Opener!...Great Toaster...Love this color and it works great! Great price as well

    Product Description

    A stylish plum toaster with extra-wide slots, six shade settings, and four easy-to-use functions.
    See all Toasters
    Your price for this item is $29.99
    Save $10
    The previous price was $39.99

  2. Bella - Fits-anywhere Kitchenware: 4-Slice Slim Toaster with Long Wide Slots - Oatmilk

    SKU: J3P5RPJ6FS

    Love it. Looks great on my kitchen counter...Best toaster ever...Love the 4 slices slim toaster. This helps get toast done quicker for large families....The heat settings are great.

    Product Description

    A slim oatmilk-colored toaster with extra-long slots, bagel preset, and slide-out crumb tray for convenience.
    See all Toasters
    Your price for this item is $39.99

  3. KitchenAid - 4-Slice Toaster with Illuminated Buttons - Contour Silver

    SKU: J3KHV8CLJQ

    The best toaster we have ever owned. Toasts bread and bagel evenly. Easy to use and keep clean....Never had a toaster last a year, it gets used everyday, great product...Best toaster I ever owned...Great...

    Product Description

    A contour silver toaster with extra-wide slots, illuminated chrome buttons, and dual independent controls for even toasting.
    See all Toasters
    Your price for this item is $99.99

  4. Bella - 2-Slice Toaster - Surf

    SKU: J3P5RPJ9H9

    GREAT PRODUCT ✨...So far it’s great! I love the color. I love the way it fits my counters....Love my toaster, works great and looks darn good.

    Product Description

    A stylish surf blue toaster with extra-wide slots, six shade settings, and four easy-to-use functions.
    See all Toasters
    Your price for this item is $29.99
    Save $10
    The previous price was $39.99

  5. Bella - 2-Slice Toaster - Oatmilk

    SKU: J3P5RPJS58

    Love the color. Works great....Adorable toaster looks great in my kitchen. Very feminine and perfect. I love it.

    Product Description

    An oatmilk-colored toaster with extra-wide slots, six shade settings, and a modern, soft matte finish.
    See all Toasters
    Your price for this item is $29.99
    Save $10
    The previous price was $39.99

  6. Bella - 4-Slice Toaster - Blossom

    SKU: J3P5RPJ6FX

    The best...tried it with bagels I tried it with English muffins and everything toasted up perfectly I absolutely love...Love it...I love that it is a 4 slice toaster and that it has numerous settings....

    Product Description

    A pink toaster with extra-wide slots, six shade settings, and a removable crumb tray for easy cleanup.
    See all Toasters
    Your price for this item is $44.99
    Save $15
    The previous price was $59.99

  7. KitchenAid - 4 Slice Programmable Toaster, 120V - Black Matte

    SKU: J3KHVG2FX9

    Great toaster!...We bought this toaster and love it! Toasts evenly. Works smoothly. Easy to use....Works so well and looks great, too!

    Product Description

    A programmable black matte toaster with extra-wide slots, adjustable shade control, and a durable metal design.
    See all Toasters
    Your price for this item is $199.99

  8. Nostalgia - Retro 2-Slice Bagel Toaster - Red

    SKU: J3GW7GFV7X

    Great looking toaster...Great looking toaster! Nice color scheme and controls. Toast came out perfectly on first use!

    Product Description

    A vibrant red toaster with two wide slots, five browning levels, and illuminated control buttons.
    See all Toasters
    Your price for this item is $39.99

  9. Nostalgia - Retro 2-Slice Bagel Toaster - Pink

    SKU: J3GW7GVJRK

    Product Description

    A retro pink toaster with two wide slots, five browning levels, and illuminated control buttons.
    See all Toasters
    Your price for this item is $39.99

  10. Bella - Fits-anywhere Kitchenware: 2-Slice Slim Toaster with Long Wide Slot - Surf

    SKU: J3P5RPJ9Q8

    Product Description

    A slim blue toaster with an extra-long slot, auto shut-off, and BPA-free, easy-clean design.
    See all Toasters
    Your price for this item is $24.99
1-18 of 176 items
0 items

Best Sellers

Related Pages

FAQ

When choosing a bagel toaster, consider features such as dedicated bagel settings, adjustable browning controls, extra-wide slots for thicker bagels, and removable crumb trays for easy cleaning. Some toasters also offer defrost and reheat functions for added convenience.

The bagel setting typically toasts only the cut side of the bagel while gently warming the outer side. This ensures a crispy interior and a soft exterior, perfect for enjoying your favorite bagels just the way you like them.

Yes, most bagel toasters can also handle other bakery items such as English muffins, thick artisanal bread, and pastries. The extra-wide slots and adjustable settings make them versatile for a variety of breakfast treats.

Extra-wide slots allow you to toast thicker items like bagels, Texas toast, or specialty breads without them getting stuck or unevenly toasted. This feature adds versatility to your toaster, accommodating a wider range of baked goods.

To keep your bagel toaster in top condition, regularly empty the removable crumb tray and wipe down the exterior with a damp cloth. Avoid using abrasive cleaners, and never immerse the toaster in water. For stubborn crumbs, gently shake the toaster over a sink.