Explore the Logitech Gaming Keyboards Collection
Logitech - G513 Carbon RGB Wired Gaming Mechanical GX Blue Switch Keyboard - Carbon
User rating, 4.7 out of 5 stars with 255 reviews.
4.7(255 Reviews)- 5 Expert Reviews
- 8 Answered Questions
How it's going to work:
- Every few minutes, we're going to release more inventory.
- Shortly, the button below will turn back to yellow (unless we sell out).
- At that point, try adding it to your cart again.
Pro Tip: If that works, checkout as fast as you can. It won't be reserved until you are in checkout. Good luck!
Special Offers
Cardmember Offers
carousel
Description
Features
GX Blue Mechanical Switches
Offer rapid response times for quick in-game action.
Multimedia controls
So you can adjust audio settings while in-game.
Adjustable keyboard height and palm rest
For added comfort and support.
Integrated numeric keypad
Allows simple data entry when you're not gaming for multifunction use.
USB interface
Enables a simple wired connection to your computer.
Windows compatible
For use with your existing computer.
What's Included
- Keycap puller
- Logitech G513 Carbon RGB Wired Gaming Mechanical GX Blue Switch Keyboard
Manuals & Guides
Key Specs
- Lighting TypeRGB
- Form FactorFull-size
- Keyboard TechnologyMechanical
- Key Switch TypeGX Blue
- WirelessNo
General
- Product NameG513 Carbon RGB Wired Gaming Mechanical GX Blue Switch Keyboard
- BrandLogitech
- Model Number920-008924
- ColorCarbon
- Color CategoryBlack
Feature
- Lighting TypeRGB
- Customizable LightingYes
- Numeric KeypadYes
- TouchpadNo
- Keyboard TypeGaming, Programmable
- Palm RestYes
- FoldableNo
Function
- Form FactorFull-size
- Keyboard TechnologyMechanical
- Dedicated Macro KeysYes
- Adjustable Tilt FunctionYes
- Key Switch TypeGX Blue
- Key Switch BehaviorClicky
- Multimedia KeysYes
- Internet KeysNo
Connectivity
- WirelessNo
- Number Of USB Port(s)1
- Interface(s)USB
- Cable Length5.9 feet
Compatibility
- Operating System CompatibilityWindows
- Plug and Play OperationYes
- System RequirementsMicrosoft Windows 7 / 8 / 8.1 / 10
Dimension
- Product Height1.3 inches
- Product Width17.9 inches
- Product Weight36 ounces
Included
- Additional Accessories IncludedKeycap puller
Mouse
- Mouse IncludedNo
Warranty
- Manufacturer's Warranty - Parts2 years
- Manufacturer's Warranty - Labor2 years
Other
- UPC097855141873
Customer rating
Rating 4.7 out of 5 stars with 255 reviews
(255 Reviews)Expert rating
Rating 4.2 out of 5 stars with 5 reviews
(5 Reviews)Customer images
Search
- Pros mentioned:Design, Keys, LightingCons mentioned:G keys, Switches
Rating 5 out of 5 stars with 1 review
Click, Clack, Top of the Pack
Posted .Pros mentioned:Design, Keys, LightingCons mentioned:G keys, SwitchesLogitech’s G513 Carbon with GX Blue Switches is a new entry into Logitech’s mechanical keyboard range, updating the G512 by swapping the Romer-G switches for the new GX Blues. These switches are modeled after the popular MX blue style switches which are now made by many manufacturers, and Logitech saw it fit to include them in a svelte offering that blends in with the dark keyboard crowd but packs some excellent gear that’s sure to please typists and gamers alike. A disclaimer: mechanical keyboards are very subjective. My preference for blue switches will undoubtedly lead me to favor this model over other offerings, and I have done my best to present the merits and shortcomings of the keyboard neutrally. Please sample this keyboard at a Best Buy store prior to purchase to determine if the switches are right for you. - Packaging and Design Continuing Logitech’s trend to transition to minimalist packaging, the G513 comes as barebones as it gets, with the only in-box documentation being a notecard for warranty information and a quickstart guide with the Logitech support web address. Given that this is a keyboard, however, with the setup consisting of pretty much just “plug it in,” this makes sense. The G513 Carbon is an impressive slate keyboard with a brushed aluminum/magnesium alloy comprising the base plate. It has some weight to it, but most of the anti-skid comes from the rubber feet; the back two of which flip-down to give the keyboard an angle for those who prefer it. Floating (frameless?) keycaps mean cleaning the keyboard is an air-duster breeze. Keycaps appear to be doubleshot PBT, resulting in clean, uniform RGB lighting across the board. As this is a standard 104-key US keyboard with a slim base, there are no dedicated G keys as there are on some other offerings by Logitech, but these can still be assigned to the function row. Along the backside of the keyboard, a passthrough USB 2.0 port (not 3.0, sadly) means a wireless mouse receiver or other device can be directly connected, and in the event that device is a headset, a channel running underneath the keyboard (and palmrest) can keep the cord and keyboard flat along the table during gaming. Unfortunately there is no headphone or microphone passthrough. Curiously, Logitech included a 1/4” tripod mount at the rear of the keyboard, but this is not mentioned in any documentation or online features. It is possible this is for a future accessory, or was intended to be used as a microphone mount for streamers or a cell phone mount for use with future Logitech HUD software. - Performance & Use Logitech’s GX Blue switches are nothing short of excellent. They have a slightly higher actuation force than typical MX blue switches, but the post-actuation resistance seems higher than MX blues, resulting in what I perceive as a smoother “click” than competing blue switches. The switches are perfectly consistent across the board with no noticeable variation in force or smoothness, which is crucial for any keyboard. Key actuation is similarly consistent throughout, and across the keyboard the point at which a stroke is registered is below the breakover. There were no instances where I accidentally hit a key with my fingers resting on it. In day-to-day use I found my typing speed was equal to my prior keyboard, which was also a blue-switch style keyboard that was getting long in the tooth. Gaming performance was similar as well, and while I was originally bummed that I lost dedicated hotkeys from my old board, I found I did not miss them after several weeks of use. The G513 includes a keycap puller tool and a set of concave keycaps for the Q/W/E/R, A/S/D/F, and 1-5 keys, and though they are not my preferred keycaps, they felt every bit as solid as the standard caps. One thing for which I was grateful the keyboard has is a standard assortment of media keys from F9 through the Pause key, which I use routinely to control movies and music. Another set of four alternate-function keys from F5 through F8 control the keyboard’s lighting and gaming modes, all customizable through Logitech’s provided software. - Customization: Software There are currently two Windows companion apps available for the keyboard: Logitech’s Gaming Software and the Logitech G Hub. The latter is currently in an open beta and is not yet feature-complete. Using either the Logitech Gaming Software or Logitech G Hub, the lighting on the keyboard is fully adjustable on a per-key basis, including brightness (by reducing the RGB color values). Fully programmable animations are possible on both softwares, but the Gaming Software currently has a selection of applets available that can animate the keyboard when events happen in other apps or games. For example, during police chases in an open-world crime game, the keyboard can flash alternating red and blue lights like a police cruiser, and notifications from messaging apps can cause the top row (or any set of keys) to flash to draw attention to them. I found the notifications useful for when I had the sound muted or my headset off. Both the Gaming Software and G Hub apps allow the function row to have up to 12 macros programmed and ready to go with one touch. These can be toggled always-on or off until Fn is pressed. Like with prior Logitech gear, macros are intuitive and easy to set up, and can perform mouse button functions in addition to keyboard commands. Additionally, as the keyboard does not have dedicated Num Lock or Scroll Lock indicator lights, the Gaming Software can overlay their statuses when they are toggled, along with Game Mode and G-Shift (function row macro/keyswap). - Customization: Hardware Those who like to install dampeners under the keys will find their options a bit more limited. The design of the stock keycaps is such that they have cross-members in the plastic that remove landing pads from consideration. Fortunately, standard o-rings work just fine despite an odd-shaped support. With 0.4mm (blue) rings installed, they provide sufficient sound reduction to not overpower a headset microphone and reduce the post-actuation throw comfortably. The switches themselves use a standard MX-style mounting platform and should accept any compatible keycap set...provided you find a set that matches the stock keycaps’ unusual dimensions. With a 108mm wide base, the spacebar is thinner than the common 6u bars while still being larger than 5.5 units, and the bottom row’s dimensions of 1.5u / 2x 1.25u / [spacebar] / 3x 1.25u / 1.5u do not seem to match any common layouts. It may be some time before aftermarket options appear, if the demand materializes at all. I did not take the keyboard apart so I can’t speak to PCB quality nor the possibility/difficulty of swapping switches. - Bottom Line It was surprising to find Logitech as competitive in the mid-to-high end mechanical keyboard space as they are with the G513 Carbon. The longer I used the keyboard (two weeks as of this writing), the more I liked it, and it didn’t take long at all for me to pack away my old mechanical keyboard and switch to this full-time. A couple minor disappointments quickly faded and left behind a fantastic full-size keyboard that I enjoy using for all purposes. It may not appeal to the mechanical keyboard die-hards, but that was not the point. This premium keyboard earned its premium price tag, and so long as you enjoy its GX Blue switches, you’ll enjoy this keyboard day-in and day-out. Highly recommended!
I would recommend this to a friend - Pros mentioned:Design, Keys, Lighting
Rating 5 out of 5 stars with 1 review
For Gamers and TYPISTS!
Posted .Pros mentioned:Design, Keys, LightingIf you’re a typist or a fan of the loud 80’s IBM clicky sounding keyboards and their tactile feel, there’s allot to like here. No 80’s mullet required. The keyboard feels solid and heavy. This will not slide or move unless you want it to. The keys are tall and mounted on top, so it’s a bit higher than the thin business keyboards that come with PC’s. The supplied palm rest helps with the height and is easy to clean. Unlike the noisy keyboards that went away as shared office space came in, there’s no empty void under the keys with on top of the base. As a result, no crumbs, hair, or other gunk will build up. A cleaner keyboard should work better, remain consistent, and last longer. The palm rest is well padded except at the edges, where my wrists seem to lay. The rest has a hard edge around the padding. Think of a pan filled with foam. An improvement would be to cut the edge down and have the padding extend to the edge or wrap over the edges. It’s not terrible, but could be better. They keyboard cable has two USB 2.0 plugs. You can use just one USB port for the keyboard and leave the second disconnected. The second cable is strictly for the USB 2.0 port on the keyboard. If you plug them into USB 3.x ports, you are still limited to USB 2.0 speed and power. The USB 2.0 port is located the back edge the keyboard by the ‘G’ logo. It’s useful for plugging in and/or charging a mouse. Because its limited to USB 2.0, backing up to a USB drive will be much slower than to a USB 3.x port. The software that manages the LED lighting is powerful. There are several effects, even one that lets the lights respond to music. Per Logitech’s web site, lighting profiles are available for 623 games as of late August, 2018. Only keys groups that are used in the game light up, and in different colors to help you quickly find them. Software updates will add new games as they come out. You can create your own keyboard layout picking defined colors from the presets or a pick a custom color from a wheel, then adjust the brightness to your exact liking. Then store it in your keyboards RAM so you can use it on a PC without the Logitech software. The lighted keys are nice for general work in a dim room as well. A warm red glow with 50% brightness worked well in the dark without being intrusive. There is minimal light bleed under the caps, barely noticeable, nothing that detracts. The keyboard also comes with a tool to remove the key caps. There are replacement keys for the Q, W, E, R, A, S, D, 1, 2, 3, 4, and 5 keys that have a different feel. These are the keys used by most popular games and help you find keys by feel. I bought this with the intention of using this for games and my wireless keyboard for work. It’s been a week and the wireless keyboard never made it back, its future looks bleak. This keyboard proved more versatile than I ever expected. It’s a solid hit. Logitech missed a market when they labeled it a ‘Gaming keyboard’ as its appeal is much broader than gaming, where it does excel.
I would recommend this to a friend Features
Quality1 out of 5Value1 out of 5Ease of Use5 out of 5Rating 1 out of 5 stars with 1 review
Garbage
|Posted .Owned for 10 months when reviewed.Features
Quality1 out of 5Value1 out of 5Ease of Use5 out of 5Garbage. The secondary keys are not lit and impossible to see at night. Do NOT BUY!!
Features
Quality1 out of 5Value1 out of 5Ease of Use5 out of 5No, I would not recommend this to a friendBrand response from Logitech
Posted .Hello KCom, we are so sorry to hear that the G513 keyboard did not meet your expectations. The G513 keyboard was built and designed with Gaming in mind. We wanted to optimize the gaming feel with a wide variety of switches and a comfortable wrist pad for long gaming sessions. We apologize for the inconvenience of the secondary characters not lighting up. Have a great day. -Ricky|Logitech
- Pros mentioned:Comfort, Keys, Noise
Rating 5 out of 5 stars with 1 review
Possibly the best keyboard I've ever used
Posted .Pros mentioned:Comfort, Keys, Noise** The Good ** This is one solid keyboard, thanks to having an aluminum case, which also gives the G513 a very distinctive look compared to keyboards from other manufacturers. The build also give the keyboard some serious heft, so there’s no worry about the keyboard sliding on your desk, even during intense gaming moments. The key switches, while they are not Cherry MX Blue, are extremely responsive and have a very satisfying (and loud) audible feedback. Logitech created their own switches to compete with Cherry MX, and they did an excellent job. Included in the box are extra keycaps and a keycap puller, allowing you get the most out of the G513 for as long as possible. Included in the box is also a very comfortable palmrest. It doesn’t attach to the keyboard, so you’re free to adjust and move it to whatever position feels the most comfortable to you. It has rubber feet on the bottom, so it shouldn’t slide around on your desk while in use. Logitech included a USB type A port on the back of the keyboard to allow you to charge your phone or any other device, since the G513 keyboard does require two USB type A ports on your PC to function. I don’t have a shortage of USB ports on my tower, but it’s still a nice feature that Logitech included. After downloading the Logitech Gaming Software, you can create your own custom macros and select what RGB light pattern you want, or you can just choose to be boring and have a solid, permanent color. ** The Bad ** Honestly, the only thing that I could possibly nitpick about the G513 is the lack of dedicated physical macro keys. However, you can create your own special macros using Logitech’s Gaming Software (see screenshot). ** Bottom Line ** The Logitech G513 is an excellent choice if you’re looking to buy a new mechanical keyboard. It has a very solid and premium build. The key switches, while not Cherry MX, are still extremely tactile, responsive, and sound great. When paired with the Logitech Gaming Software, you can customize the keyboard’s RGB patterns/effects and create your own custom gaming macros.
I would recommend this to a friend - Pros mentioned:Comfort, Design, Keys
Rating 4 out of 5 stars with 1 review
Responsive but Clicky
Posted .Pros mentioned:Comfort, Design, Keys---SETUP--- The setup for the Logitech’s G513 gaming keyboard is simple. After plugging it is, the computer recognizes it. Go to the website in the provided documentation to download the associated software to unlock it’s full potential. ---FEATURES--- The key feature of this keyboard is its customization options and access to existing gaming profiles. Customization-wise, this keyboard has it’s keys flash like a rainbow. This is optional if you find it distracting, but it looks very nice every time to press a key. The software detected games I already had install on my PC and asked if I wanted to download profiles for those games. I did so and it didn’t take long. It includes a very comfortable and oversize wrist rest, perfect for log sessions (though the wrist rest doesn’t attach to the keyboard itself, like my previous gaming keyboard). Additionally, it also has a USB 2.0 on the back, perfect for a wireless mouse receiver. I did notice it lacks a volume control on the keyboard itself. ---PERFORMANCE--- The performance of this keyboard is great. It is very responsive and accurate when gaming. When customizing it with the downloadable software, you can edit your gaming keys and program multiple settings as well as save well over 10 profiles for different games you play. ---EXPECTATIONS--- The product meets my expectations. In the video games I tested, I didn’t notice anything that would cause me to not recommend this keyboard. However, when you press on the keys, you will notice that the keys have a clicking noise that you may not be used to. Since I game with a headset on, I don’t hear it during gameplay. However, if using this to work and type documents, you may find it noticeable. Keep this in mind when purchasing. ---VALUE--- The price for the keyboard in terms of value is on par with its competitors. The lack of an on-keyboard volume control was a noticeable lacking feature but the oversized wrist rest compensates for that, as it is very comfortable. ---APPROVAL--- I highly recommend this product for gamers who seek to customize their keyboard and have some added flair. It is a very well constructed keyboard and the wrist rest pad is one of the most comfortable ones I’ve ever used.
I would recommend this to a friend - Pros mentioned:Keys, Noise
Rating 5 out of 5 stars with 1 review
Fantastic Keyboard - LOVE LOVE LOVE IT!
Posted .Pros mentioned:Keys, NoiseI really love light-up keyboards. I've had one ever since the Logitech G15 (Original blue-LED model) came out, but I've also always loved mechanical-switch clicky keyboards dating back to the IBM Model F keyboard as my words-per-minute goes up about 20 words on them (not sure why!) This keyboard rates right up there with the best of them for me - best of both worlds with extremely bright light-up keys that can be individually colored and those wonderful mechanical switches. Seriously, I pouted when I went back to work the next day after getting this as the keyboard on my work computer felt like typing on wet cotton balls after using the G513! The wrist rest is also quite nice - it feels good and it doesn't slide around. I've seen some folks call it memory foam. I don't think it is, but it does have a nice firm feel about it. If you're looking for a keyboard, run out and try this one - you'll love it (if you don't mind the noise - which I don't!).
I would recommend this to a friend - Pros mentioned:Comfort, Keys
Rating 5 out of 5 stars with 1 review
Not your grandma's keyboard
Posted .Pros mentioned:Comfort, KeysThis may look like just your average keyboard at first glance, but don't be deceived; the Logitech Gaming G513 Wired Mechanical keyboard is anything but average. It has so many options for customization that it actually is somewhat overwhelming. It is very simple to plug-and-play however the real fun comes when you download the software and get to tinker around with all the options. However, that is also one of the drawbacks. For a noob, it may be somewhat diffucult to navigate through all the options and fortunately the software comes preloaded with a few set ups to play with including one for gaming. I love the illuminated keys for gaming because sometimes my hands get out of place and it's very easy to get back on the right spot with a quick glance. The keyboard itself feels very sturdy and does not take up any more space on your desk than it needs. It also comes with a comfortable wrist cushion and extra buttons for replacement. The feel of the buttons is very smooth however, like all mechanical keyboards, is also loud and sounds like you're typing on an old typewriter. It is also very responsive and works great for gaming. I would recommend this to anyone in the market for a gaming keyboard as it definitely holds its ground against the higher end gaming keyboard competitors and is from a very reputable company.
I would recommend this to a friend Features
Quality4 out of 5Value2 out of 5Ease of Use5 out of 5Pros mentioned:KeysCons mentioned:CharactersRating 2 out of 5 stars with 1 review
Not for first time typist&lost design opportunity
|Posted .Owned for less than 1 week when reviewed.Features
Quality4 out of 5Value2 out of 5Ease of Use5 out of 5Pros mentioned:KeysCons mentioned:CharactersI purchased this keyboard since PC Magazine online 2020 reviews indicate that this keyboard is "Best for Heavy Typists Who Are Also Gamers". My previous Dell keyboard after a decade finally bit the dust, and it was time to find a good mechanical keyboard that can handle heavy typing + use it for gaming. After using this keyboard for a couple of days, I am giving this keyboard 2 stars due to: * Upper shift characters lack illumination and they are swapped, compared to "normal" keyboards. If you are not a seasoned typists and had not memorized the QWERTY configuration, you're going to be be confused when you type on this keyboard then you go to work using a traditional keyboard. the number keys on the top row (below the function keys) are swapped. See photo for difference. Now, if the "upper" characters illuminated when you press the Shift key (or with caps lock on), this would not be an issue. However, Logitech did not put this design on this keyboard, and for $130, that is a major oversight. * No Num lock indicator. If you use the numeric keypad on the right, there is no way for you to tell if the Num lock is on or off. You just have to test it beforehand. * No USB 3.0 support. The keyboard uses 2 USB ports, and it has a USB passthrough port on the right back. This only support USB 2.0, not USB 3.0. Even if you have a USB 3.0 ports or hub, it will downgrade your USB passthrough to USB 2.0. Again, for $130, this is a stupid oversight. Luckily, I have a large USB 3.0 hub with 10 ports, so I can live with this design limitation. The feel of the keyboard is fine for typing. It does come with a nice sturdy wrist rest, so from a general use standpoint, the keyboard is fine. Just be aware of the above differences and you decide if you can live with them (or not). Ensure you also get the online manual from Logitech support web page. There is no manual with the keyboard, just the link info to get the manual. You will need it to learn how to turn off or change the flashing psychedelic colors illuminating from all the keys, which was the default setting. At least you do not need to install the Logitech gaming software to change the keyboard light settings.
Features
Quality4 out of 5Value2 out of 5Ease of Use5 out of 5No, I would not recommend this to a friendBrand response from Logitech
Posted .Hello, I am sorry to hear you are not satisfied with the product. Thank you for taking the time to write this review, we appreciate the feedback.
Rating 4.2 out of 5 stars with 5 reviews
(5 Reviews)- Tom's GuideRating, 4 out of 54.0Marshall Honorof on June 25, 2018Logitech G513 Keyboard Review: 2 Flavors of ExcellenceWhen you get right down to it, the G513 is a relatively simple keyboard. True, it introduces a new type of key switch, and it has RGB lighting, which jacks up the price a bit. Other than that, it's just well-built and responsive, without any bigFull Review
- PCMagRating, 4 out of 54.0Gabe Carey on May 25, 2018Logitech G513 CarbonThough it cries out for media/macro keys, the minimalist Logitech G513 Carbon gaming keyboard justifies its price with custom, RGB-lit mechanical switches that feel great and won't wake up your household.Full Review
- PCWorldRating, 4.5 out of 54.5Hayden Dingman on June 1, 2018Logitech G513 review: Attractive outside, new Romer-G switch insideLogitech's G513 is more than an attractive, professional-looking keyboard. It's also the debut of the new Romer-G Linear switch, a faux-Cherry MX Red that finally gives Logitech lovers some options.Full Review
- SlashGearEric Abent on April 27, 2018Logitech G513 Review: A great (but expensive) keyboard for the RGB-obsessedIf you're looking for an RGB mechanical keyboard, there are plenty out there to choose from. Many gaming keyboards these days have started using mechanical switches instead of membrane ones, and while most of those seem to use some kind of CherryFull Review
- Vortezvortez.net on September 21, 2018Logitech G513 Review - GX Blue SwitchWe've already put the Logitech G513 with the Romer-G switches through its paces, so will the G513 with GX Blue switches be just as good?Full Review
Q: QuestionCan you change the color of the keyboard to one solid color?
Asked by EmmettB.
- A:Answer Sure can.
Answered by Reggie
Q: QuestionMy laptop only has 2 USB ports and one is for my wireless mouse. Since this keyboard requires the use of 2 USB ports, could I use one of the USB port splitters or hubs to make it work? I won't be using the keyboard for gaming, if that makes a difference.
Asked by clareify.
- A:Answer The keyboard doesn’t require two ports, one is for the on keyboard usb port, another one is actually for the keyboard, so there’s nothing to worry about.
Answered by Marvinnnnn
Q: QuestionSo it says that it is the linear keys but in the product images it shows that it has the gx blue keycaps that are featured on logitech's website. which one is it?
Asked by Sam.
- A:Answer Based on the part number listed on this page and whats listed on the Logitech website this is the GX Blue version. PART NUMBER Silver, Romer-G Tactile Switch: 920-008721 Carbon, Romer-G Tactile Switch: 920-008860 Carbon, Romer-G Linear Switch: 920-008848 Carbon, GX Blue Switch: 920-008924
Answered by Neg1
Q: QuestionWhen are they going to restock on the linear switches.
Asked by Adam.
- A:Answer my best quess is 2054 or the next centennial
Answered by marcbcar
Q: QuestionDoes This Work With Ps4? If yes I will buy it. If Not Which Keyboard Does Best Buy Have The Work With Ps4.
Asked by Shivam.
- A:Answer Yes it works with a ps4. Thats all I use it for.
Answered by Rednecking
Q: QuestionDoes this keyboard work well with MAC OS? Does it require a driver or is it plug and play?
Asked by TJ1989.
- A:Answer Hello, this particular keyboard is designed for Windows OS. It can work for mac but does not have any specific mac keys such as 'cmd' and also we do not offer support for mac.
Answered by Logitech
Q: QuestionIs there anyway to raise the volume, lower the volume, or mute the volume?
Asked by Anonymous.
- A:Answer Yes. The F keys all have a special function that can be accessed by holding down the FN key and then pressing the corresponding F key. You can pause/play tracks, skip tracks, and adjust volume plus many more functions.
Answered by DM88
Q: QuestionHow do I put the volume up and down and mute.
Asked by Anonymous.
- A:Answer I believe you have to hold the FN key on the bottom right while using the desired keys.
Answered by Caleb