Alexander [Hong Kong] [DVD] [2004]

The vast majority of our reviews come from verified purchases. Reviews from customers may include My Best Buy members, employees, and Tech Insider Network members (as tagged). Select reviewers may receive discounted products, promotional considerations or entries into drawings for honest, helpful reviews.

• Rated 5 out of 5 stars

  This Is How It Should Be Done

  • Incentivized
  • Verified Purchaser
  • My Best Buy® Member

  I originally sat on the fence in my opinion of the theatre release of Alexander, but Alexander Revisited has won me over as admirer of the film. The new cut has a truly epic feel and the leading characters are portrayed with more breadth and depth. In particular, the climactic crises of Alexander's career are conveyed more intelligibly and convincingly than before. I am the author of both academic articles and non-fiction books on Alexander, so I feel I should comment particularly on the historical accuracy of the film. In my opinion Alexander Revisited is notably honest, daring and sincere in its pursuit of historical accuracy. Although Oliver has deliberately conflated events which actually occurred at different times and places into single scenes (I think he had to in order to tell the whole story in a single film), almost everything has some kind of historical basis in the group of 2000 year old accounts, which provide most of our knowledge of Alexander. For example, such details as Cleitus severing the arm of a Persian about to strike Alexander, the incident with the monkeys in India and Alexander's visit to the wounded after the battle are all in the sources. Even that eagle is mentioned by Curtius. Furthermore, many snippets of dialogue are based on words actually said to have been spoken by Alexander: e.g. "He too is Alexander", "So would I if I were Parmenion", "It is a lovely thing to live with courage..." Great attention to historical detail was also paid to the costumes and scenery. Babylon was particularly good - the ziggurat, the flowers and the caged big cats were all really there when Alexander drove into the city in a chariot. Overall, Alexander Revisited gives a more authentic sense of the real history than any other film about the ancient world that I can think of. Gladiator was a great film, but its greatness owed more to Marvel comic strip principles of action and violence than to its setting in ancient Rome. Alexander Revisited is a great film because it tells one of the most compelling human stories in all of history with faithfulness, drama and pathos.

  This review is from Alexander Revisited: The Final Cut [Unrated] [2 Discs] [DVD] [2004]

  Posted 11 years ago by DDunnDatBoi

• Rated 3 out of 5 stars

  ok

  • Incentivized
  • My Best Buy® Elite Plus Member
  • Verified Purchaser

  ok moie I enjoyed it..................................

  This review is from Alexander Revisited: The Final Cut [Unrated] [2 Discs] [DVD] [2004]

  Posted 6 years ago by Varnadore

• Rated 5 out of 5 stars

  You HAVE to see this movie!!!

  • Incentivized
  • My Best Buy® Elite Plus Member
  • Verified Purchaser

  Complex history and a very complex man. The writers and director do an excellent job of tackling a very difficult, larger-than-life historical mover and shaker. You will be spellbound by the scenes, cinematography, and CGA sets. Almost all of the actors are first rate and infuse life, humanity, and pathos into their character. You will not be disappointed with this tour de force. Some nudity so keep it away from the kids - this is real life!!!

  This review is from Alexander Revisited: The Final Cut [Unrated] [Blu-ray] [2004]

  Posted 11 years ago by RWBennett