I've owned several Alienware machines in the past, but never one of their laptops -- they've always just been a bit too heavy and bulky. This new m17 R2 is finally thin and portable enough that I was very excited to get my hands on it. As expected, it has that futuristic-looking Alienware design and excellent performance, but also some drawbacks that are borderline unacceptable at this price point. It's an awesome gaming laptop -- as long as you know what you're buying into.
=== DESIGN ===
- I'm a big fan of Alienware's new Lunar Light color. It's kind of an eggshell white with a very nice matte texture. Even the wrist area and keyboard are covered in this beautiful white finish. It's a refreshing change from the typical black color of most gaming laptops.
- When closed, the laptop 15.7" wide by 11.6" deep. At under 6 pounds, it must be one of the lightest 17-inch gaming laptops available.
- The RGB keyboard looks excellent contrasted against the Lunar Light finish. The LED strip surrounding the black shroud at the rear of the laptop is a great addition, though you really can't see it while using the laptop. The laptop's power button is an Alienware RGB logo that changes colors based on the laptop's status -- for instance, it glows yellow when you are using battery power.
- Unfortunately, Alienware's Command Center software used to customize the RGB lighting is horribly confusing and buggy. It often fails to retain my settings, crashes frequently, and required 3 or 4 different updates upon opening it for the first time.
- There are plenty of ports available on the m17. On the right: Two USB 3.1 Type-A ports. On the left: One USB 3.1 Type-A port, a gigabit Ethernet jack, and a headphone jack. On the rear: One Thunderbolt 3 port, HDMI, mini DisplayPort, and Alienware's proprietary port for its Graphics Amplifier.
- The power brick is huge and must weigh half as much as the laptop itself, but that's one of the tradeoffs of having a laptop this powerful and thin.
- Overall: Make room for the power brick in your backpack. Also, I wish there were an additional USB-C port somewhere on the laptop. Alienware also needs to go back to the drawing board on its Command Center software. Those minor things aside, this is an incredible looking laptop with all of the connectivity options that a gamer could need.
=== DISPLAY, KEYBOARD, & TRACKPAD ===
- This model is equipped with a 17.3-inch 1080p display running at 144Hz. The display is excellent and I'm very content with 1080p at this size. Colors are rich and vivid, black levels are very deep, and the matte screen does an excellent job reducing glare. There is the tiniest bit of light bleed in the bottom left corner of my display, but it's hardly a deal breaker. Sure, a 4K OLED option would be great, but you would sacrifice refresh rate and battery life. As such, this 1080p panel at 144Hz is a great option.
- The keyboard is very large and comfortable. It has a nice amount of travel (reported to be 1.4mm) and it takes a satisfying amount of force to depress the keys. I wish there was some more tactile feedback from the keys, but overall, it's a great keyboard.
- The trackpad uses Windows Precision drivers and is outstanding. It works perfectly with gestures and is extremely responsive.
- Also standard on the m17 is Tobii eye tracking, located in the bottom bezel below the screen. It looks to be pretty neat technology, but I only own two games that support it: The Division 2 and Shadow of the Tomb Raider. (Fun fact: if you purchase this laptop by November 30, you'll get a free key for Ghost Recon Breakpoint in the Tobii app). In The Division 2, the camera pans based on where you're looking, and staring at the same place long enough brings up the aiming cross-hairs. It's a cool feature to have, but I wouldn't base any laptop/PC purchase solely on this technology.
- Overall: Alienware has nailed the basic aspects of a 17-inch laptop with an outstanding display, keyboard, and trackpad.
=== PERFORMANCE, COOLING, & UPGRADES ===
- Let's start with the bad stuff: namely, the glaring lack of upgradability. Most notably, the RAM is integrated onto the motherboard and cannot be upgraded past 16GB. Also, this particular m17 model includes a last-generation Wireless AC card, not a next-gen (Wi-Fi 6) AX card. And just like the RAM, the wireless card cannot be upgraded.
- The speakers are acceptable, but nothing more. They work fine, but there is noticeable distortion at higher volumes and they sound tinny and hollow to me.
- This laptop has some of the most advanced eye tracking technology available for PCs, but it does not support Windows Hello (facial recognition log-in), which boggles my mind.
- Now the good stuff: The laptop performs exceptionally well. It has handled every game I've thrown at it with ease. Shadow of the Tomb Raider (high settings; RTX high; 65 fps); Metro Exodus (high settings; RTX high; 50-55 fps); Gears 5 (Ultra settings; 60 fps). An RTX 2080 would have been nice to squeeze out some better ray tracing performance, but I'm perfectly satisfied with the performance of the 2070 and the i7-9750H.
- The laptop gets HOT. There's no getting around it. Luckily, the fans aren't overly loud and the speakers easily drown out any fan noise. Most games push the GPU temp to upwards of 75°C, and the CPU to over 80°C. So no, you probably won't want to game with this on your lap.
- Battery life what you would expect for a powerful gaming laptop -- acceptable, but nothing more. Browsing the web with the screen at half brightness resulted in about 3.5 hours of battery life. Obviously, gaming is going to result in even shorter battery life
- Overall: If it's upgradability you're looking for, you may want to look elsewhere (like Alienware's new Area 51m laptop). Besides adding more SSD storage, you won't be doing any major upgrades to the m17. Luckily, performance out of the box is outstanding and should satisfy most gamers looking for a portable gaming laptop.
=== OVERALL ===
My biggest gripe is the inability to upgrade the RAM on the m17. At the very least, I wish Alienware would have offered the m17 with 32GB of RAM so buyers could futureproof if they wanted to. The clunky Alienware software and lack of Windows Hello support are also head-scratchers that could have (and SHOULD have) easily been addressed. Regardless, I'm very excited to have a laptop this beautiful, this powerful, and this portable. Recommended -- as long as you're aware of the upgrade limitations.